[papa_levante]

Is that possible?

I think it has happened twice. I noticed karma from one user and then in just a couple of minutes, it was gone.

Is it a bug in the system, or can users change their minds about having given karma?

[Hanne]

no karma can't be withdraw..

I can only think of 3 reasons

1) bug in the system

Speculation (I don't know if the following would cause removal of karma)

2) If the karma'ed post is deleted, would the karma note disappear ?
If you remember which post it was given to, you could check to see if the post is still there.

3) The member had his/her account deleted (Accounts can only be deleted if the member has few or none posts).

[Diamond Star]

Was the karma new or at the bottom of the list? If it is the latter, it's been bumped off the page by new karma (not all your karma points & comments are kept).

I hope that makes sense

[tangerine]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hanne ... 2) If the karma'ed post is deleted, would the karma note disappear ? If you remember which post it was given to, you could check to see if the post is still there....

I am pretty sure that if a post is deleted, the karma goes with it. That is a vBulletin default AFAIK.

[fairy]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hanne no karma can't be withdraw.. I can only think of 3 reasons 1) bug in the system Speculation (I don't know if the following would cause removal of karma) 2) If the karma'ed post is deleted, would the karma note disappear ? If you remember which post it was given to, you could check to see if the post is still there. 3) The member had his/her account deleted (Accounts can only be deleted if the member has few or none posts).

im almost sure thats the reason...happened to me yesterday and i know the post got deleted