One of my favorite is Korres lip butter in guava it smells delicious and it melts into the lips, they feel soft and moisturized and its made out of natural products.
SPF is super important especially for the lips since the skin that is coating the lips is thinner and therefore more sensitive.
It was kind of expensive but I really liked the Ojon Tawaka lip care bundle. It was an oily exfoliant and leave on cream. Does anyone remember labello chapstick? Those were great too (and cheap) but I can't find them anywhere anymore! I have a suspicion nivea took over.
I like to stick with drugstore brands when it comes to lip balms, as they usually work really well. Aquaphor is amazing to use before you go to sleep and good ol' Chapstick (or Chapstick Naturals) for daytime. I don't like a lot of shine.