out of all of them, i find mary kates the most unique. i agree with others that the other smaller ones look far too much like someone took their chloe betty and threw it in the washing machine. how punk rock: not!
i also see hints at MJ's sweet punk line with the studs. so he chose to use spikes instead of pyramid studs? okay..i think MJ's were more hardcare and more original.
i find a lot of alexander wangs stuff tries to be edgy but he doesn't usually push the designs far enough, or borrows a bit too much from other designs. just my two cents though.
^ totally agree, he used the idea of metal purse feet and took it to a new level, and made it edgy. if he needs to turn out like 10 bags, 9 of which have been done, and 1 which is something new, more power to him. i really do love the MK one.