The Model & Celeb Weight Thread [Read post #1 before posting] #1

[Boomer]

Originally Posted by carmen_kass

Her downfall really started after the whole Carson Daily (is that his last name?) episode happened, or rather ended. I wonder if she'll be on Dancing with the Skanks?

Yes- she'll be competing against Brandon Davis, Britney, her sister and her mother- also the entire Hilton family...

Oh and Lindsay's Ex-Rockette mother...

[carmen_kass]

Let's not forget Brody Jenner, because without him it just wouldn't be classy. He'd date Anna Nicole's corpse if he thought it would further his "career".

[fashion_love]

Originally Posted by Boomer

I so agree! When I met her it was by accident, I didn't even realize it was her for a minute...And not only was she very beautiful, but she was actually very nice too! We chatted for a long time about where we grew up- she lived a couple of towns over from where I lived, and she was sweet (much to my surprise...) So I have a somewhat different opinion of her- I think she just may be a pretty nice kid who has had a lot of problems...

I've seen Tara Reid at the Ocean's 13 premiere this year in June and she looked absolutely fabulous, this weightloss is so sudden, I can't believe it.

[Boomer]

Originally Posted by fashion_love

I've seen Tara Reid at the Ocean's 13 premiere this year in June and she looked absolutely fabulous, this weightloss is so sudden, I can't believe it.

That's disturbing, what with her history of problems...

[carmen_kass]

Yeah, E! News said she's lost around 25 lbs in six weeks. Considering she's 5'5 they estimated her weight at around 120 or so lbs and she's down to about 95. Allegedly.

[BonjourTristesse]

So sad. Tara Reid...

[fairy]

Originally Posted by seanutbutter

I don't understand, why did you post this picture? You didn't provide any commentary, nothing to accompany the photo - it just seems like you're spamming the thread with pictures of various models. I don't mean to come off as rude, but I'm just curious as to why you decided to share that with us (especially since the topic at the time was Tara Reid).

i dont mean to come off as rude either but there isnt a rule about which pictures to post here...and just because everyone else is talking about Tara doesnt mean ppl have to 'stay on topic'
whats the point of picking on him the whole time? everyone has the right to post pictures here...
plus does a picture of a dangerously skinny model really need any commentary?

[jssy4eva]

I understand where you're coming from fairy, but in seanutbutter's defense, certain people here have the habit of constantly posting pictures of certain models (Olga, Kim Noorda, Siri and so on) yet get extremely protective whenever people mention their favorite model. They'll take pictures of the aforementioned models and compare them to their favorite and imply that because so and so is not as frail as they are, then she must be healthy. Sometimes, they do it even when no one is talking about their model. THe point is, that if you read this thread enough, it becomes annoying. This thread used to be full of really good discussions and it still is to a point, but it's also filled with a lot of anger and people taking things far too personally.

[fairy]

so? who says your opinion is worth more than for example superFashion's?
and im reading this thread...
just ignore it if its so annoying to you...
i personally dont give a fcuk about Vlada, Olga, Kim, Tara or whoever is skinniest at the moment...but whats the point of this thread (or any other) if ppl arent allowed to express their opinion...as long as its not rude...and as far as im concerned...superFashion was never rude to any other member on here even though there were alot who were rude to him! thats my point...
i think not the picture he posted, but seanutbutter's comment about it was off-topic, asking him whats his point of sharing it...whats the point of that?

[AnaBGD]

Originally Posted by fairy

so? who says your opinion is worth more than for example superFashion's?
and im reading this thread...
just ignore it if its so annoying to you...
i personally dont give a fcuk about Vlada, Olga, Kim, Tara or whoever is skinniest at the moment...but whats the point of this thread (or any other) if ppl arent allowed to express their opinion...as long as its not rude...and as far as im concerned...superFashion was never rude to any other member on here even though there were alot who were rude to him! thats my point...
i think not the picture he posted, but seanutbutter's comment about it was off-topic, asking him whats his point of sharing it...whats the point of that?

yeah, I agree.
but it seems to me that this thread has become something like curve appreciation thread. and most people can't respect the fact that some others prefer skinny, and then start attacking them and posting all the Vlada, Olga etc. pics to prove that skinny is not attractive!

[fairy]

yes they cant respect it because skinny=sick and ppl who prefer skinny to curvy=sick/annoying/silly/etc
but i was talking about superFashion in particular...and he's posting pics of Vlada because he likes her/her body...whats wrong with that?
look through the last 2-3 pages...how many ppl have posted pics of Tara Reid? so whats the point of all these pics of Tara? she's skinny in each of them
ppl are just taking the p*ss out of superFashion all the time, being disrespectful and putting him on a kinda 'podium'
its okay to do that as long as they can all go on with 'their topics' right?

[jssy4eva]

I don't think my opinion is worth more than his. I don't think anyone's thoughts should be valued more another person's. All I'm saying is that if you read this thread often enough it gets to be a bit too much. I do agree with you, sometimes people pick on certain members for no reason and I don't like that at all; nobody deserves to be treated like that. It brings down the community. Yes, we can ignore it, but I think it's a bit more complicated than that.

[carmen_kass]

^Very well said AnaBGD, it's also become the case that being skinny means you're unhappy, ill, a victim of malnutrition and worst of all "NOT A REAL WOMAN". Vlada may be thin, but she's not prosthetic. Nicole Richie is as skinny as any other model, and she's frequently being acused of not being "a real woman", well then how did she get pregnant?

There's a lot more to a woman than her curves btw.

[*Bianca*]

but it seems to me that this thread has become something like curve appreciation thread. and most people can't respect the fact that some others prefer skinny, and then start attacking them and posting all the Vlada, Olga etc. pics to prove that skinny is not attractive!

damn, can we just get one definition straight at least?

curves is not a substitute for the word fat
skinny women can be curvy too

[jssy4eva]

^Exactly!

I just want to take this moment to say that *Bianca is a superstar*!