Bee Shaffer vs. Julia Restoin-Roitfeld: Who wins?

[taperjeangirl]

Originally Posted by SuGaR_rUsH

Julia no doubt. She has that unattainable vibe, a bit kate moss-esque crossed with jane birkin. Bee is just plain boring and she is a terrible writer.

Your post says it all

[kanita]

Julia in style, Bee in beauty.

[thesiren]

bee's writing is TERRIBLE. columbia teaches you to write like THAT?! ana should be asking for her money back.

julia is like a little doll with an edgy streak. mothers aside, she's clearly the one with more style and has a real knack for dressing like a modern girl. bee is boring. when you're that young, that connected and that gorgeous, why dress the same way you'll have to when you're 50?

[kiki96]

Does anyone have any really recent photos of either girl. I know there was recently a party in their honor (and for Margherita Missoni) but I haven't seen any pictures from it.

off topic a bit, but I adore Margherita -- she is so cute!

[cutxpaste]

Ms. Julia!

[anaisanais]

julia hands down

[leblue15]

julia !!!! julia!!! I feel that she has a better style, Bee dresses nice but boring!!.

[Alliecat]

Julia...

[lola01vip]

i think we all agree that Julia is the big winner!

she seems A) more down to earth (from the reading of itw) has a better sense of fashion

while Bee seems too classical (as her mother i think)...

[fullfrontal]

I like Julia's style and look moreso than Bee's but who in their right mind plays dress alike with their mother and in cheetah print at that. That aside, I've always love Bee Schaffer's name. But she dresses very plain even by New York society standards. I'd like to see what she wears on a regular basis. And I agree that she should not be publishing any writing if that article is an indication of her level of writing.

[TheGlassAngel]

I love Bee. I like her elegance and her style although I must say, I completely understand why someone would pick Julia. She's got this certain...carefree vibe that I like as well

[Skirt]

Bee's really pretty but I prefer Julia, she has a snap to her that Bee doesn't.

[baguette]

Julia is much older than Bee
They have age difference
Very difficult to compare

[satin chic]

^ How old is Bee? I know that Julia is 26.

[TheGlassAngel]

19, I think...