Vogue Paris December / January 11.12 : Kate Moss by Mert and Marcus - Page 13

congacon · 02-12-2011

raquel's ed looks quite good.

silk skin paws · 02-12-2011

On the cover the wig is too obvious-looking. It looks like a cheap Halloween throw away wig. The editorials are much better.

Melancholybaby · 02-12-2011

Raquel's ed is good but it stands alone.

Bretonne · 02-12-2011

The new eds are slightly better especially Karmen's.

Psylocke · 02-12-2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by ada_looo

I should thank Alt for helping me save $$

Karmen's and Raquel's editorials are mediocre at best. Numéro does the dark editorials with Karmen so much better than this. And Raquel's ed would probably have been slightly more exciting if they had used Aymeline Valade or someone else that we haven't seen a million times in Sims' boring studio eds before.

mikel · 02-12-2011

Raquel's ed is not bad. But I feel like I've seen this type ed a million times already.

MON · 02-12-2011

En Scene & Queen of Noise are really nice! I just don`t know about Last Night.

tentacules97 · 02-12-2011

Aline's and karmen's ed are perfection.
Raquel's and Arizona are okay.
Sasha's do nothing for me.
BTW who's the other girl in Giampalo Sgura's " En Scene"???

mikel · 02-12-2011

^ Shannan Click.

VogueDisciple93 · 02-12-2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by ada_looo

I should thank Alt for helping me save $$

The cover and all the editorials so far are immensely underwhelming. I don't find them has heinous as some people do, but they are incredibly boring and unoriginal.

agee · 02-12-2011

Well Alt has produced a quintessential Roitfeld issue - a strong and impactful cover with mediocre contents. My question is why even do a music themed issue when every issue has music / rock-inspired eds as that is Alt's thing.

More Than A Woman (Arizona Muse by Inez Van Lamsweerde & Vinoodh Matadin and Emanuelle Alt) - There is nothing new here, but it is still a strong ed - Arizona really brought it.

Let's Dance (Sasha Pivovarova by Terry Richardson and Marie Chaix) - There are a couple of good images like Sasha sitting on the steps, but overall she looks so bored and over it and not in a good way. The styling is meh - the set is nice but expected given the theme.

En Scene (Aline Weber and Shannan Click by Giampalo Sgura and Geraldine Saglio) - Nice but nothing special especially for an issue of VP, but at least it was not 10+ pages of nothing special.

Queen of Noise (Raquel Zimmermann by David Sims and Emanuelle Alt) - Same ish, different wig. I personally like the styling but it is still same old - same old.

Last Night (Karmen Pedaru by Hedi Silmane and Melanie Ward) - Despite its one-note-ness, I think that this is one of the better eds in the issue.

thiago:) · 02-12-2011

I love Raquel's editorial! The styling isn't the best, but the result was great. The red background shot is my favorite (guess I have a new wallpaper

).
Last Night is also amazing! I love everything, even the hairstyle.

liberty33r1b · 02-12-2011

after seeing Raquel's ed I'm just really glad I won't be buying that issue....

GivenchyHomme · 02-12-2011

Such utter garbage in this issue. Everything is over stylized and generic looking. I thought Kate's cover was terrible but it's nothing compared to the content. In regards to Karmen's editorial, they could have just put a wig on a mannequin if they were only going to end up shooting it in the exact same pose six times. ALT has wasted no time destroying this magazine.

Fashion-screen.livejournal.com via jenna16, fordmodelsfashion

TeeVanity · 02-12-2011

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bretonne

Aline looks super gorgeous.

She really does!

FAQ	Calendar	Search	Today's Posts	Mark Forums Read	Rules	Links	Mobile	How to Join

02-12-2011	181
congacon fashion insider Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Toronto Gender: homme Posts: 2,291	raquel's ed looks quite good.
Status: Online

02-12-2011	183
Melancholybaby V.I.P. Join Date: Aug 2011 Location: Greece Gender: homme Posts: 5,563	Raquel's ed is good but it stands alone. __________________ An oasis of horror in a desert of boredom

02-12-2011	186
mikel V.I.P. Join Date: Sep 2005 Gender: homme Posts: 22,769	Raquel's ed is not bad. But I feel like I've seen this type ed a million times already. __________________ "I'm not sorry... I'm sorry that I didn't make it clear that it was a joke. But I can't be sorry for what I said—it's against my nature." Lars von Trier

02-12-2011	187
MON V.I.P. Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Philippines Gender: homme Posts: 5,922	En Scene & Queen of Noise are really nice! I just don`t know about *Last Night. __________________ TWITTER:* @monxx \| INSTAGRAM: mondimac

02-12-2011	182
silk skin paws doldrums Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: corporations are people too Gender: femme Posts: 1,347	On the cover the wig is too obvious-looking. It looks like a cheap Halloween throw away wig. The editorials are much better.

02-12-2011	184
Bretonne rising star Join Date: Sep 2011 Gender: femme Posts: 162	The new eds are slightly better especially Karmen's.

02-12-2011	188
tentacules97 backstage pass Join Date: Sep 2011 Gender: femme Posts: 535	Aline's and karmen's ed are perfection. Raquel's and Arizona are okay. Sasha's do nothing for me. BTW who's the other girl in Giampalo Sgura's " En Scene"???

02-12-2011	189
mikel V.I.P. Join Date: Sep 2005 Gender: homme Posts: 22,769	^ Shannan Click. __________________ "I'm not sorry... I'm sorry that I didn't make it clear that it was a joke. But I can't be sorry for what I said—it's against my nature." Lars von Trier

02-12-2011	191
agee V.I.P. Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: Georgia Gender: femme Posts: 5,773	Well Alt has produced a quintessential Roitfeld issue - a strong and impactful cover with mediocre contents. My question is why even do a music themed issue when every issue has music / rock-inspired eds as that is Alt's thing. More Than A Woman (Arizona Muse by Inez Van Lamsweerde & Vinoodh Matadin and Emanuelle Alt) - There is nothing new here, but it is still a strong ed - Arizona really brought it. Let's Dance (Sasha Pivovarova by Terry Richardson and Marie Chaix) - There are a couple of good images like Sasha sitting on the steps, but overall she looks so bored and over it and not in a good way. The styling is meh - the set is nice but expected given the theme. En Scene (Aline Weber and Shannan Click by Giampalo Sgura and Geraldine Saglio) - Nice but nothing special especially for an issue of VP, but at least it was not 10+ pages of nothing special. Queen of Noise (Raquel Zimmermann by David Sims and Emanuelle Alt) - Same ish, different wig. I personally like the styling but it is still same old - same old. Last Night (Karmen Pedaru by Hedi Silmane and Melanie Ward) - Despite its one-note-ness, I think that this is one of the better eds in the issue.

02-12-2011	192
thiago:) she's got the look Join Date: Nov 2007 Gender: homme Posts: 5,328	I love Raquel's editorial! The styling isn't the best, but the result was great. The red background shot is my favorite (guess I have a new wallpaper ). Last Night is also amazing! I love everything, even the hairstyle. __________________ *

02-12-2011	193
liberty33r1b V.I.P. Join Date: Nov 2003 Location: Manchester, UK Gender: femme Posts: 22,846	after seeing Raquel's ed I'm just really glad I won't be buying that issue.... __________________ "he waited for other people to understand what he was doing, instead of doing what they wanted. Balenciaga never compromised."

02-12-2011	194
GivenchyHomme trendsetter Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Via Fogazzaro 36 Gender: homme Posts: 1,387	Such utter garbage in this issue. Everything is over stylized and generic looking. I thought Kate's cover was terrible but it's nothing compared to the content. In regards to Karmen's editorial, they could have just put a wig on a mannequin if they were only going to end up shooting it in the exact same pose six times. ALT has wasted no time destroying this magazine. Fashion-screen.livejournal.com via jenna16, fordmodelsfashion

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode