Vogue Paris February 2008 : Kate Moss & Naomi Campbell by Mario Testino - Page 8

ponytrot · 18-01-2008

oh hell!

Kanna · 18-01-2008

Thanks for cover pic and preview, everyone!

SnejanaIsMyMuse · 18-01-2008

Isabeli's edit=love

Perfect

*ana* · 18-01-2008

the more i look at the cover the more i love it

**Luxx** · 18-01-2008

I want to love this but so far none of the edits have clicked for me yet. Excellent concepts but the execution seems off. Isabeli as Winehouse is too literal for me - its been done already by Numero and it doesn't work as well for me here. Isabeli doesn't really capture Amy's descent - she still looks too clean and glamorous. I'm almost reminded instead of an old Richardson edit with Isabeli dressed in chonga fashions. Either way I think I'll have to see the full edit or something in order to appreciate things.

Kate and Naomi fall flat for me - I actually hate Naomi's hair pulled back like that on the cover.

Kept woman Natasha looks like the most interesting thing thus far though if they were going for Anna Nicole Smith they should have cast someone else.

I want to love this issue, I really do. I I see something else in it that blows my mind soon.

Starry · 18-01-2008

I love the cover! Two supermodels!
All the eds seem interesting so far and I can't wait to see the complete scans!

Thanks for the preview guys!

**dior_couture1245** · 18-01-2008

LOVE Natasha's golddigger editorial!

The best picture is her pushing her sugar daddy in his wheelchair!

LOVE Isabeli as Amy...I would have never made the connection, but she looks perfect as Ms. Winehouse (except Isabeli is a better version of Amy!

)

Lily's editorial is great, but not as striking or memorable as the other two.

Kate and Naomi's is pretty good. This is definitely not Kate's greatest work, but Naomi looks KILLER on the cover and in the shoot!!!

Diorette · 19-01-2008

I love what I've seen so far!

I was hoping Kate would be on the cover.

Can't wait to receive this!

kissmesweet · 19-01-2008

I don't like the cover. Kate makes it look so lifeless, but Naomi looks fierce.

I love Isabeli, but I like how they're portraying her as Amy Winehouse.

flyingace · 19-01-2008

Lily's ed is the only thing I like so far, and maybe Natasha's, but I'm not really excited about it.
I don't like the cover, Kate has a bored expression. And their ed, it looks like a series of boring portraits.

Dieselmax · 19-01-2008

HQ Cover:
Photo by Mario Testino

Scanned by me.

There's a whole new layout inside. Not sure if I like it...

Review:

Kate & Naomi
Photographer : Mario Testino
Fashion Editor : Carine Roitfeld
Models : Kate Moss & Naomi Campbell

Just Married!
Photographer : Terry Richardson
Fashion Editor : Emmanuelle Alt
Model : Natasha Poly

American Dream
Photographers : Inez Van Lamsweerde & Vinoodh Matadin
Fashion Editor : Carine Roitfeld
Model : Lily Donaldson

L'Idole
Photographer : Peter Lindbergh
Fashion Editor : Emmanuelle Alt
Model : Isabeli Fontana

Givenchy, Des Hommes, Des Femmes
Photographer : Mario Sorrenti
Fashion Editor : Carine Roitfeld
Model : ?

Bon Mauvais Goût
Photographer : Mario Sorrenti
Fashion Editor : Carine Roitfeld
Model : ?

Ordre du Jour
Photographer : Patrick Demarchelier
Fashion Editor : Marie-Amélie Sauvé
Model : ?

Most Wanted
Photographer : Mario Sorrenti
Fashion Editor : Carine Roitfeld
Model : Sasha Pivovarova

Dieselmax · 19-01-2008

There are a few models I couldn't recognize

They may be new faces.

sassyposh · 19-01-2008

i love it.. so nice to have two of the greatest supermodels in one extraordinary vogue cover....

sassyposh · 19-01-2008

first we had that iD cover with gemma ward and lily donaldson.. and now this, naomi and kate in one cover...

Is being a duo in a cover the new trend? definitely.

kissmesweet · 19-01-2008

Quote:

I love Isabeli, but I like how they're portraying her as Amy Winehouse.

Sorry for the moment of incoherency. I meant to say that... "I don't like how they're portraying her as Amy Winehouse."

Thanks for the cover scan, Dieselmax. Can we expect some scans?

18-01-2008	#106
ponytrot V.I.P. Profile: Location: in Xanadu did Kubla Khan a stately pleasure dome decree.. Gender: femme Posts: 4,107	oh hell! __________________ World enough and time...
	Reply w/ Quote

18-01-2008	#107
Kanna ㅎㅎ™ Profile: Gender: femme Posts: 8,652	Thanks for cover pic and preview, everyone!
	Reply w/ Quote

18-01-2008	#108
SnejanaIsMyMuse tfs star Profile: Location: Ohio Gender: homme Posts: 1,576	Isabeli's edit=love Perfect
	Reply w/ Quote

18-01-2008	#109
ana V.I.P. Profile: Gender: femme Posts: 4,308	the more i look at the cover the more i love it __________________ my mother was right: when you've got nothing left, all you can do is get into silk underwear and start reading Proust.
	Reply w/ Quote

18-01-2008	#110
Luxx disgusted. revolted. Profile: Mod Squad Member Location: NYC Gender: femme Posts: 5,770	I want to love this but so far none of the edits have clicked for me yet. Excellent concepts but the execution seems off. Isabeli as Winehouse is too literal for me - its been done already by Numero and it doesn't work as well for me here. Isabeli doesn't really capture Amy's descent - she still looks too clean and glamorous. I'm almost reminded instead of an old Richardson edit with Isabeli dressed in chonga fashions. Either way I think I'll have to see the full edit or something in order to appreciate things. Kate and Naomi fall flat for me - I actually hate Naomi's hair pulled back like that on the cover. Kept woman Natasha looks like the most interesting thing thus far though if they were going for Anna Nicole Smith they should have cast someone else. I want to love this issue, I really do. I I see something else in it that blows my mind soon. __________________ "I have grown tired of apologising for being in this profession. I know that clothes are not important, that I am not changing society." - Miuccia Prada *SANS ARTIFICE.COM* - Fashion Without Fakery
	Reply w/ Quote

18-01-2008	#111
Starry tfs star Profile: Gender: homme Posts: 1,853	I love the cover! Two supermodels! All the eds seem interesting so far and I can't wait to see the complete scans! Thanks for the preview guys!
	Reply w/ Quote

18-01-2008	#112
dior_couture1245 On Your Video Phone Profile: Mod Squad Member Location: NY Gender: homme Posts: 5,383	LOVE Natasha's golddigger editorial! The best picture is her pushing her sugar daddy in his wheelchair! LOVE Isabeli as Amy...I would have never made the connection, but she looks perfect as Ms. Winehouse (except Isabeli is a better version of Amy!) Lily's editorial is great, but not as striking or memorable as the other two. Kate and Naomi's is pretty good. This is definitely not Kate's greatest work, but Naomi looks KILLER on the cover and in the shoot!!! __________________ "DIOR, NOT WAR!" - My motto
	Reply w/ Quote

19-01-2008	#113
Diorette * * * * * * * Profile: Location: Paris Gender: femme Posts: 6,090	I love what I've seen so far! I was hoping Kate would be on the cover. Can't wait to receive this! __________________ Les scans de Diorette
	Reply w/ Quote

19-01-2008	#114
kissmesweet we are bonded for life Profile: Location: Hong Kong. Gender: femme Posts: 18,272	I don't like the cover. Kate makes it look so lifeless, but Naomi looks fierce. I love Isabeli, but I like how they're portraying her as Amy Winehouse. __________________ ♥'s colourmefashion
	Reply w/ Quote

19-01-2008	#115
flyingace dudeist Profile: Gender: homme Posts: 1,257	Lily's ed is the only thing I like so far, and maybe Natasha's, but I'm not really excited about it. I don't like the cover, Kate has a bored expression. And their ed, it looks like a series of boring portraits. __________________
	Reply w/ Quote

19-01-2008	#116
Dieselmax trendsetter Profile: Location: Paris Gender: homme Posts: 1,435	HQ Cover: Photo by Mario Testino Scanned by me. There's a whole new layout inside. Not sure if I like it... Review: Kate & Naomi Photographer : Mario Testino Fashion Editor : Carine Roitfeld Models : Kate Moss & Naomi Campbell Just Married! Photographer : Terry Richardson Fashion Editor : Emmanuelle Alt Model : Natasha Poly American Dream Photographers : Inez Van Lamsweerde & Vinoodh Matadin Fashion Editor : Carine Roitfeld Model : Lily Donaldson L'Idole Photographer : Peter Lindbergh Fashion Editor : Emmanuelle Alt Model : Isabeli Fontana Givenchy, Des Hommes, Des Femmes Photographer : Mario Sorrenti Fashion Editor : Carine Roitfeld Model : ? Bon Mauvais Goût Photographer : Mario Sorrenti Fashion Editor : Carine Roitfeld Model : ? Ordre du Jour Photographer : Patrick Demarchelier Fashion Editor : Marie-Amélie Sauvé Model : ? Most Wanted Photographer : Mario Sorrenti Fashion Editor : Carine Roitfeld Model : Sasha Pivovarova __________________ "Shut your mouth and read that damn magazine, girl" - Tiffany Pollard aka. New York
	Reply w/ Quote

19-01-2008	#117
Dieselmax trendsetter Profile: Location: Paris Gender: homme Posts: 1,435	There are a few models I couldn't recognize They may be new faces. __________________ "Shut your mouth and read that damn magazine, girl" - Tiffany Pollard aka. New York
	Reply w/ Quote

19-01-2008	#118
sassyposh front row Profile: Gender: homme Posts: 255	i love it.. so nice to have two of the greatest supermodels in one extraordinary vogue cover....
	Reply w/ Quote

19-01-2008	#119
sassyposh front row Profile: Gender: homme Posts: 255	first we had that iD cover with gemma ward and lily donaldson.. and now this, naomi and kate in one cover... Is being a duo in a cover the new trend? definitely.
	Reply w/ Quote

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode