Vogue UK November 2008 : Jourdan, Eden & Rosie by Emma Summerton

[AnaBGD]

Cover is OK, I like it mostly because it's not single girl.
I can't say i like Karlie's ed though, is she trying to look sexy?...

[Skywire]

I'm back!

I'll start scanning Guin's ed now, seen as it's the only other one
I think 3 editorials per issue should be compulsory. It's pretty padded out this month aswell, i'll have to have a look through to see with what exactly

[Luxx]

GO EDEN!!!!! This is major for her.

[Miss Dalloway]

This is one of the most drab, unappealing covers i haver ever seen, and its even more sad since its featuring models, tallk about missed potential. First of all what a stupid cast, Jourdan should have been on the cover alone, this Eden girl does nothing for me and how on earth does she deserve a Vogue cover?Rosie is the only one who looks semi good here, oh and thats it?They dont have an edit inside?

Yawn, UK Vogue is such a joke!

[Skywire]

Postcards From The Edge
Model: Guinever Van Seenus
Photographer: Tom Craig
Pages: 16


[scanned by me]

..............

[Faith Akiyama]

I think the cover makes sense commercially...Jourdan has evidently received a lot of publicity for breaking barriers, but Rosie is also receiving press because of a significant takeover as Burberry's pointgirl -- both of them would sell the issue well. Eden, with Prada and Burberry's appreciation behind her, might be seen as a "next-gen" of sorts, although I'm not sure her work beyond that scope has necessaily reflected that. Nevertheless, I would say that she's making some headway with her appearance by balancing out the cover (An androgynous and clean-cut look as opposed to Rosie's more sultry, commercialized appeal). After the likes of Lily and Agyness, these three definitely seem poised to inherit the torch.

It does, however, shock me that there's little inside for these girls Now that does not make sense commercially!

[maffam]

i also think it helps that rosie is dating ronnie wood's son and gets quite a bit of attention for it...

[Skywire]

[scanned by me]

[OhJane]

really uninspiring

[sethii]

Congrats British vogue on making Jourdan look hideous, and for being too scared to give her an only girl cover when you gave Aggy two of them already. In fact, it's the most revolting British VOGUE cover I've seen in a long time. The girls look like depressed glam rock trannies.

Originally Posted by miwa

People should stop trying to make Rosie happen.

So with you on that! What a catalogue face.

Guineveere doesn't fit her story and looks very worn out and messy.

[vogue28]

I really like the cover, thanks for posting. Please tell me that that red banner is wrapped around the cover holding the supplement, and not printed in the front
Karlie's ed is the best ed I have seen in VOGUE UK in a long time

[Skywire]

Originally Posted by vogue28

Please tell me that that red banner is wrapped around the cover holding the supplement, and not printed in the front

Nope, it's right there printed on top

[Skywire]

Paint It Black
Model: Karmen Pedaru
Photographer: Mario Testino

[scanned by me]

[modela]

i think jourdann should have had a solo cover!!!

[DiamondSea]

Originally Posted by maffam

i also think it helps that rosie is dating ronnie wood's son and gets quite a bit of attention for it...

I think that's the main reason. Regardless, she looks the best of the three here The fringe does nothing for Jourdan.