While I think all of them look great, I don't really like any of these pics. They look like outtakes for the real campaign, imo. It would be much more effective if they were actually looking into the camera. I mean, it seems like they are looking at another photographer. IDK if that makes any sense to you guys
this looks like a cheap version of something Lanvin would do but then again it is macys. joan looks awful.
This is a cheap version of Giambattista Valli, and disturbingly enough there isn't too much of a difference between this and his mainline.
Is it a good thing (or was it a wise move?) that Valli's 'vision' could be so easily translated to a much cheaper market? Especially when he seems unable to break away from this vision of mid-thigh embellished shift dresses.
this looks like a cheap version of something Lanvin would do
Yep I agree. Also, even though I know that Joan has roots in catalog modeling, they look like high fashion models incompetently trying to pull off catalog modeling. Good gravy, who photographed and directed this, I hope it is not one of my favorites.