Stella McCartney F/W 12.13 : Natalia Vodianova by Mert Alas and Marcus Piggott

honeycombchild · 27-07-2012

Dreadful scan I know.. Probably M&M again..

My Scan

helmut.newton · 27-07-2012

This is so bizarre. That shot on the left is ridiculous! And the creative direction this season is pretty appalling too. That logo design and those things next to it are so pointless. I miss Stella's older advertisement campaigns. They were simple and chic. This is pretentious and over-thought. Disappointing.

GIVENCHYlover · 27-07-2012

I like it.
No logo?

honeycombchild · 27-07-2012

What do you mean? The logo is on the blue shape on the right hand image?

jacquelineo · 27-07-2012

Really?? Ducklips. Ugh.

I like the the color scheme.

IsabelMarantBoy · 27-07-2012

Stella Mccartney has got to have the worst ads every season, and this is no exception

I'll never understand them.

Northern Star · 27-07-2012

What the hell is that expression in the first pic

Really! 'I'll give you this bag, if you let me stay out late'......being that Natalia looks about 14 years old here.
Also the logo placement, looks like a kid left their toy shapes after doodling and then someone took the pictures with them left there. Very odd, and to top it all off the 2nd pic is actually pretty good.

GIVENCHYlover · 27-07-2012

Quote:

Originally Posted by honeycombchild

What do you mean? The logo is on the blue shape on the right hand image?

Oh, yeah. My brightness/contrast is extremely dark.

justaguy · 27-07-2012

Not sure about this campaign. Logo placement is horrendous and those "things" that look like guitar picks, pointless. Natalia looks nice but I'd have preferred to see the second shot in an outside setting.

ForChicSake · 27-07-2012

the close up is a bit odd but this looks ok

Mchunu · 27-07-2012

I love Natalia for Stella McCartney even when the elements of art direction and styling clash, as it does here. She always brings things together in an interesting way, for me at least, and I think she is the face to pull off all the experiments the brand attempts. The picture on the left is far from my favorite, but combined with the one on the right I can still be convinced that they've still go "it" to pull something like this off successfully.

KatherineCouture · 27-07-2012

Duck-face is horrible

Though the right shot is pretty good.

TREVOFASHIONISTO · 27-07-2012

I like this a lot. The 2nd shot a lot more, but I love the humor in the 1st

Lavieisashe · 27-07-2012

Holy moly...First pic that Natalia pursed her lips like that is really awkward.

Legolas · 27-07-2012

I like at well! loving the Neoplasticism influence. I actually like more the compostion in this campaign than the past ones... I was tired of the over-the-top crazyness and excess of visual information.

FAQ	Calendar	Search	Today's Posts	Mark Forums Read	Rules	Links	Mobile	How to Join

27-07-2012	1
honeycombchild V.I.P. Join Date: Jan 2009 Location: London Gender: homme Posts: 6,316	Stella McCartney F/W 12.13 : Natalia Vodianova by Mert Alas and Marcus Piggott Dreadful scan I know.. Probably M&M again.. My Scan
Status: Online

27-07-2012	11
Mchunu V.I.P. Join Date: Sep 2007 Gender: homme Posts: 11,086	I love Natalia for Stella McCartney even when the elements of art direction and styling clash, as it does here. She always brings things together in an interesting way, for me at least, and I think she is the face to pull off all the experiments the brand attempts. The picture on the left is far from my favorite, but combined with the one on the right I can still be convinced that they've still go "it" to pull something like this off successfully. __________________ WEBSITE!!! ABOUT-FACE Last edited by Mchunu; 27-07-2012 at 10:00 AM.

27-07-2012	15
Legolas V.I.P. Join Date: Jan 2010 Gender: homme Posts: 3,552	I like at well! loving the Neoplasticism influence. I actually like more the compostion in this campaign than the past ones... I was tired of the over-the-top crazyness and excess of visual information. Last edited by Legolas; 27-07-2012 at 11:29 AM.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

27-07-2012	2
helmut.newton V.I.P. Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: Australia Gender: homme Posts: 4,715	This is so bizarre. That shot on the left is ridiculous! And the creative direction this season is pretty appalling too. That logo design and those things next to it are so pointless. I miss Stella's older advertisement campaigns. They were simple and chic. This is pretentious and over-thought. Disappointing.

27-07-2012	3
GIVENCHYlover backstage pass Join Date: Nov 2011 Location: Freja's float Gender: homme Posts: 934	I like it. No logo? __________________ ▲ B L O G ▲ Freja, Sean, Selezneva, Clément

27-07-2012	5
jacquelineo V.I.P. Join Date: Oct 2008 Location: Minneapolis, Minnesota Gender: femme Posts: 5,764	Really?? Ducklips. Ugh. I like the the color scheme. __________________ Redhead <3

27-07-2012	6
IsabelMarantBoy backstage pass Join Date: Sep 2011 Location: United States Gender: homme Posts: 705	Stella Mccartney has got to have the worst ads every season, and this is no exception I'll never understand them. __________________ ‎"For something to be beautiful it doesn't have to be pretty." - Rei Kawakubo

27-07-2012	7
Northern Star French Chic Join Date: Apr 2006 Location: UK Gender: homme Posts: 15,919	What the hell is that expression in the first pic Really! 'I'll give you this bag, if you let me stay out late'......being that Natalia looks about 14 years old here. Also the logo placement, looks like a kid left their toy shapes after doodling and then someone took the pictures with them left there. Very odd, and to top it all off the 2nd pic is actually pretty good. __________________ 'Our lives are made up exclusively of what we are wise enough to keep in our hearts, and of what we are brave enough to throw away'

27-07-2012	9
justaguy V.I.P. Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: United States Gender: homme Posts: 14,623	Not sure about this campaign. Logo placement is horrendous and those "things" that look like guitar picks, pointless. Natalia looks nice but I'd have preferred to see the second shot in an outside setting. __________________ Frock n' Roll

27-07-2012	10
ForChicSake V.I.P. Join Date: Feb 2009 Gender: femme Posts: 12,635	the close up is a bit odd but this looks ok

27-07-2012	12
KatherineCouture fashion insider Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Russia Gender: femme Posts: 2,324	Duck-face is horrible Though the right shot is pretty good.

27-07-2012	13
TREVOFASHIONISTO V.I.P. Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: N.Y.C. Gender: homme Posts: 11,616	I like this a lot. The 2nd shot a lot more, but I love the humor in the 1st __________________ Maryna.Natasha.Sasha

27-07-2012	14
Lavieisashe rising star Join Date: Jun 2012 Location: Venus Gender: femme Posts: 120	Holy moly...First pic that Natalia pursed her lips like that is really awkward. __________________ A prayer for the wild at heart,kept in cages.