I think both tributes are very nicely done. But I agree that Sharan put a lot more emotion in her expressions/ poses etc. Also the scenery is more my cup of tea (Agy's studio-shoot is just too plain and lifeless).
i think the title of this thread is pointless. it should be a thread with all editorials of various models from different magazines, not just agyness vs. sharan.
Maybe the threadstarter only knew about these two? I think it is interesting to see the different interpretations of a tribute to MJ. I prefer the one by Sharan by miles. Much more expression and great location.