I think 16, 17 is a great age. Model's these days arent getting any younger, there are always the models that start young. 10 years ago many of the models were starting young, many not so young. Its just a generalization because when a model is 14, you notice it more so its the only thing you notice.
Being 16, 17 depending on the girl, the girl has her own mind and if shes going to go crazy in the city, its not gonna be different if she was at home. If we was gonna go crazy, she'd just go crazy and party out at home if she wasnt in New York. Imo it dosent make too much of a difference to me, theres always going to be similar types of people no matter where you are. If shes not exposed to drugs in the city, someone at school is going to show her.
Sadly, the fashion industry is the way it is- they have been recruting teenage girls since the dawning of supermodeldom (Gia was picked up at 16 and dropped out of high school to persue it). No matter what may seem acceptable, the editors and the big wigs will always do what they want to do, even if it seems like it's verging kiddie porn.
__________________
"I say, let's have happy clothes. You could reply that's frivolous in this troubled world, but do you really think dressing like an existential nun with suicidal thoughts is going to solve Bosnia?"
I really think it depends on the girl. Take Tallulah for example, she only 13 and just signed with IMG. However, she's 5"11, is 34-24-34 and has one of the strongest personalities of any girl I know. She also has an incredible agent (in Australia at scene) who is looking out for her. She nor her agent would let herself get into a bad situation.
The fashion industry is on crack. If a teenager looks like a woman, then fine, but most of these girls look like the little girls they are. Why is that considered desirable or attractive? A full-grown woman is almost invariably more attractive than her teenage counterpart.
i think 14 is i good age im just starting now and i'm 15 and its awesome. I think if i started later i would be depressed from younger girls that have worked more then me. But i also it takes alot away from school and friends.
I don't get people who are saying if they look older then it's fine. Err, shouldn't it be the other way around if shes mature enough mentaly for her age then it's fine. For example Gemma looks younger then she really is,who cares? Obviously they saw something in the girl if they signed her at such a young age.
When you talk about a model's age in general , you start as a baby, like 8 months or so. But I know you're referring to 'older' models, well more like adolescence. And my opinion about that is this... for the most part an agent/scout looks for the height and body type (first and foremost) NOT how old the girl is. Age is secondary to them. The overall appearance can be 'guesstimated'.
In defense of the photographers and agents, IF you want to be a PAID model you should have these CRITERIA to adhere: determination, dedication, and willing to do anything. I know i'm missing alot of points but i think it's these 3 that are the most talked about here. First of all, the legit agencies and photographer/s will not have you do something distasteful. And its clients are not some Hustler or Porno Magazine that they'll have a 14 or 18 yr old do semi/nude shots. If it is it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure that out. A redflag should be loud and clear and you are in a sleazy agency run by cons.
Now getting back to the age... it seems that Americans are more prudish when it comes to taking pictures in panties or bras etc and almost immoral to the extend. And being 14 or 18 even, it is deemed wrong. That's how we Americans think. But Europeans, Latins and even some Asian countries are rather open to nudity, almost natural to them. It doesn't phase them. And fashion is the same way.
Does it sound harsh? It's a JOB plain and simple. Part of a job description of a paid model.
I dont think it sounds harsh, I think you brought up all the points here that pretty much sums it up. Its part of the job, no ones manipulating the images to create kiddie porn here. Its always done in an artistic point of view, do you really think these photographers are trying to use these 15 year olds for porn? ..no.
But the comfort level of a model posing topless is a completely different part to this topic.
It sounds harsh you say? It's a JOB. Part of a job description of a professional model.
If you're 18 and feel uncomfortable to pose in skimpy clothes or whatever than you need to pose for Mc Donalds, Wendy's and the like. High Fashion and the likes are not for you.