^ I'd honestly rather see
all campaign brand castings dicussed in one thread. A bunch of split threads for each brand would be messy and more for moderators to sort through. I think we're opening a door that we don't want to if we allow some brands their own threads and not others.
Here's the runway casting thread that exists each season in ETCs, as I mentioned earlier it functions beautifully:
http://forums.thefashionspot.com/f96...-a-147383.html
Quote:
Originally Posted by Psylocke
The campaign wishlist thread is a bit pointless because people would just post "Hilary for every campaign" or "Snejana in any campaign and I'm happy" etc. but that would not lead to any discussion so a general thread for when the campaigns are out might make more sense.
|
You're probably right, it's probably not needed if we give them another place to discuss the casting, but then we need to make this thread news ONLY:
http://forums.thefashionspot.com/f79...-a-150893.html
You have to dig through that thread to find any real information. As there's lots of the exact comments you're talking about in that thread.
------------
So, next season in ETCs of Modeling:
F/W 2012 Ad Campaign Casting Discussion
And next season in Ad Campaigns:
F/W 2012 Ad Campaign Casting -- News Only
And of course the news can also be posted in the "free for all" casting dicussion thread in the ETCs.
The chat room is a brilliant idea, but I'm not convinced it will deter people from posting the same kinds of comments. It'd still be great to have though if possible.