View Single Post
06-12-2012
  168
Phuel
backstage pass
 
Phuel's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: Canada
Gender: homme
Posts: 518
Quote:
Originally Posted by kokobombon View Post
My problem with that scene is -beside the silly staring and Michonne staying silent- is that Andrea pointed a gun at her, protecting the governor... Michonne helped her and didnīt leave her behind when she was sick, Andrea could have given her the benefit of the doubt and trust that she was kicking his a$$/about to kill him for a reason.
Why would Andrea just trust that Michonne had a "good" reason to kill her man????? He's only treated her kindly, so why would she not defend him when she sees her ex-friend about to slice him in half? Andrea does not know how evil and messed up this man is; she doesn't see what us viewers see, and the fact that Michonne never reveals anything to Andrea-- not of her suspicion that the man murdered the Coast Guards, that he sent a team to murder Michonne. That's extremely sloppy, poor writing and character development for Michonne.

heelsonfire: I think the fact that it's revealed to us viewers that there's a huge gapping hole in the rear of the prison may be foreshadowing of things to come-- for better or for worse. Rick and his team obviously haven't discovered it yet, and that exposed threat is for us to know and anticipate. That is good writing, whereas the Michonne never revealing very important information other characters so that they may discover it for themselves is poor and extremely sloppy writing.

  Reply With Quote