^^^ Absolutely.
The image, the styling, the composition, the tone-- it's all so... cold-- so unlike everything I associate with Alaia. Resembles an Absolute Vodka ad.
Guinevere is one of my favs, but she's more suited for a dark cinematic glamor, or a quirkiness, neither of which I associate with Alaia. Like others have mentioned, Stephanie, Naomi, Christy or Linda would have carried a much stronger branding for Alaia's first fragrance so much better.
Very odd direction.