I don't think anything 'happened' to them, they're still miles ahead of Vogue and Elle judging purely by the covers and edits. Put this next to Karlie on Elle and Penelope on Vogue, then tell me which one is the best....
It's nice to have a festive cover, love all the rich reds and the outfit.
I think when you consider who Thomas Whiteside's major clients are, then the boringness of his work makes sense. Harper's Bazaar, Elle, InStyle. He recently did a solid edit for Interview, which was great. I'm more lenient with newer photographers trying to establish a style in this oversaturated field. It's the Testinos and Meisels, who we know to be capable of great work yet couldnt be bothered, who irks me.