MDC (Models.com) Rankings | Page 148 | the Fashion Spot

MDC (Models.com) Rankings

  • Thread starter Thread starter martinaonrocks
  • Start date Start date
like i said it before i think all the supers should be removed.
the top icons should be models who start modeling after the Supers.IMO
 
like i said it before i think all the supers should be removed.
the top icons should be models who start modeling after the Supers.IMO

I agree, even Christy or Claudia aren't doing much these days
only Naomi is getting work in campaigns ,eds, covers.
they should make a vintage old icons list where non working icons can be listed like Linda, Cindy, Verushka, etc.

The ones that have kept longevity started the works until now most have modeled in late/middle 1990's Stella T, Gisel, Kate w/ exception to Kristen and to the early 2000's era of Natalia and Liya and middle 2000s with Daria. then there are the silent working icons like Malgosia, MariaCarla.

I think the only Supers Iconic True Supermodel is Kate Moss which is long overdue of her No.1 spot. Kate Moss is the definition of a living Icon !
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm okay with MariaCarla being #20. Sure she works and does the highest end campaigns, but outside of people who really follow the industry, she's not really identifiable. I think she needs more mainstream crossover appeal to soar up the icon list.

Raquel is way too low. So is Isabeli. As for number one. There is Gisele, and then there is every other model who's ever lived. It's been that way forever, it will be that way for all times. No one will ever come close to anything remotely like the career she's put together. She shattered the mold.

Jon was taken off the male list about 5 or 6 months ago. He's being doing this for a long time but I'm not sure he'll make the icon list soon. It'd be hard justifying putting him anywhere other than #1 compared to what everyone else on that list is doing and it's a bit young for that. Same for Noah Mills.

Baptiste at #1 is annoying. He isn't the superstar we were promised Karl would make him according to MDC. And even with a KL exclusive, he doesn't have the most impressive resume of the last 1.5 years. Clement is without question tops.
 
I'm okay with MariaCarla being #20. Sure she works and does the highest end campaigns, but outside of people who really follow the industry, she's not really identifiable. I think she needs more mainstream crossover appeal to soar up the icon list.

Raquel is way too low. So is Isabeli. As for number one. There is Gisele, and then there is every other model who's ever lived. It's been that way forever, it will be that way for all times. No one will ever come close to anything remotely like the career she's put together. She shattered the mold.

Jon was taken off the male list about 5 or 6 months ago. He's being doing this for a long time but I'm not sure he'll make the icon list soon. It'd be hard justifying putting him anywhere other than #1 compared to what everyone else on that list is doing and it's a bit young for that. Same for Noah Mills.

Baptiste at #1 is annoying. He isn't the superstar we were promised Karl would make him according to MDC. And even with a KL exclusive, he doesn't have the most impressive resume of the last 1.5 years. Clement is without question tops.

Kate Moss, I know more people do know her and she earned her fame and status all by herself. although Gisel earns more she wouldnt have capitulated to stardom without getting the much needed exposure of dating celebs like Leonardo and commercial venture like VS . I first knew the name Gisel when I saw her with Leonardo. saying status is based of money and fame alone is not enough but the impact in fashion and the public alike is considered too

maybe it was just a coincidence but since discovery channel's airing of the perfect symmetrical face and using the face of Kate Moss as the perfect embodiment of female perfection and Tom Cruise for men.
Kate Moss has reined supreme as the Living Icon thus she
earns the Top No.1 Spot !

I agree Baptiste at No.1 is a Joke, he is beginning to look like a Troll appearing in background ads for Chanel , Fendi etc. sorry :sick:
Clement, Simon even Sean should take the No.1 spot. Ben Hill needs to be moved to the icons list
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Liya just got the balenciaga campaign

but she is with a million other girls.

about mcb, i think she got blue chip campaigns consistently but the majority were multigirl compaigns.

cover wise, mcb doesnt do too well in this area. same goes with eds for the big 4 vogue editions. this girl just doesnt do well in prints.
 
but she is with a million other girls.

about mcb, i think she got blue chip campaigns consistently but the majority were multigirl compaigns.

cover wise, mcb doesnt do too well in this area. same goes with eds for the big 4 vogue editions. this girl just doesnt do well in prints.

Liya although is in a multi Balenciaga campaign but she had been signed to L'Oreal contract ? beauty contracts are big too like Natalia with Guerlain, Daria with Lancome or Carolyn with Estee Lauder. so that makes up for it altough Liya has been lacking any covers or editorials for years.

about MariaCarla; although she rarely gets covers or apear in editorials
the big blue chip campaigns season after season for a decade proves her longevity is iconic too. Cavalli, Givenchy, Prada, Dolce and many more
 
is funny to me how MCB get many campaigns but not many many covers/eds
why would that reason be? maybe designers pick her for the campaing,but then photographers dont really like her?
 
i dont think a l'oreal contract is as prestige as lancome or estee lauder bc literrally there are a million models front ads from l'oreal.

anyway it is still a big contract, however i dont think liya has enough work to get her back to the icon list. bc mcb is standing at 20 and i dont see how liya has more works than mcb
 
is funny to me how MCB get many campaigns but not many many covers/eds
why would that reason be? maybe designers pick her for the campaing,but then photographers dont really like her?

that would be odd since most photographers who shoot campains also shoot for covers/eds,
but she did have get her first big Vogue Italia cover last year. which was one of her biggest Magazine covers ever

i dont think a l'oreal contract is as prestige as lancome or estee lauder bc literrally there are a million models front ads from l'oreal.

anyway it is still a big contract, however i dont think liya has enough work to get her back to the icon list. bc mcb is standing at 20 and i dont see how liya has more works than mcb

well Liya isn't doing much these days, which I was surprised since she popped up in Balenciaga considering she hasn't had any Covers or hard eds for years now. I think Liya or Linda could make way if Lara is moved to the icons list. Linda is iconic but isn't doing much these days too.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
if any one cares Rosie Huntington Whiteley is number 3 at the sexiest models list

Rosie has been No.3 for a couple of months now :huh:

the biggest mover Irina Shayk moved to No. 10 :sick:
and Anne Vyalitsyna who was no.18 and now moving up to No. 14 must be all the covers and Campaigns she is getting season after season.

Biggest Flop goes to Doutzen Kroes
who previously occupied No.2 spot and is now down to No. 9
 
Girls that moved up:

Joan to #4
Liu to #6
Arizona to #7
Jac to #9
Sigrid to #12
Saskia to #14

Girls tha moved down:

Sasha to #5
Miranda to #8
Iris to #10
Eniko to #18
Trentini to #28 (but I think she re-entered the list :unsure:)
Siri to #42

Juliane debuted at #29
 
Jan at No.4. really ? :judge:
and Juliane debut is too high

she still hasn't even have 1 magazine cover
and limited editorials with us vogue
great news for Jac, Sigrid and Saskia !

jamie bochert did not move and still there
Carolini was put back in the list, so why not Jessica and Lily too ? :huh:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
^ Juliane is on the cover of the current Vogue Italia.

I meant Joans, she just gets us vogue editorials and not even a regular
and above Sasha and she moved down again :cry: .
Daphne at No. 15 is too low, Daphne should already be Top 10

Miranda at Top 10 is still not just justifiable no matter how popular your boyfriend is. maybe they need her supplemented her presence with Candice at somewhere around No. 30
 
^Joan is US Vogue regular, she repeats Gucci, she has Estee Lauder Contract and is said to be in David Yurman campaign. As for the big covers she has one: i-D Fall 2010. Maybe I wouldn't put her at the same spot as Karlie, but she's definitely Top 5 force atm.

I think Sasha is slowly moving to the more commercial territory, which is kinda amazing considering how totally not commercial she is :D
 
I agree that Miranda shoud be moved down. Okay, she was pregnant and so on but business is business.
 
^Joan is US Vogue regular, she repeats Gucci, she has Estee Lauder Contract and is said to be in David Yurman campaign. As for the big covers she has one: i-D Fall 2010. Maybe I wouldn't put her at the same spot as Karlie, but she's definitely Top 5 force atm.

I think Sasha is slowly moving to the more commercial territory, which is kinda amazing considering how totally not commercial she is :D

well just because Sasha is doing more commercial work she is moving down? Sasha has 5 Campaigns in her bag , although most are more commercial not that HF but still

Paul&Joe
Hugo Boss
Juicy Couture Fragrance
Biotherm Eaux Body Spray
1 local polish ad

I know Joans 1 iD Fall cover but that was last year but oh well must have been her Estee Lauder contract, FeiFei should also move up
I agree Joan is Top 5 but moving to 4 is too early, she needs to be around for more years, the Top 5 are models mostly established for more than 5 years with the exception to Abbey.
 
Juliane debuted at 29 because of a campaign and cover?
please...

I find this MDC list to be so biased especially when the can't even accurately keep up with work that models are getting. If anything Fashiongonerogue should have a top model list
 

Users who are viewing this thread

New Posts

Forum Statistics

Threads
215,601
Messages
15,308,611
Members
89,625
Latest member
nickem7
Back
Top