MDC (Models.com) Rankings

[congacon]

i didnt mean to insult u but your constant posts about freja got a bit silly.

by the way, how do u even consider arizona, karmen and karlie have longevity? these girls have been around for only a few years. they are not newbies but considering them as having longevity is a bit silly.

 

[alonsoJonathan]

^ n karmen hasnt done sh!t I really dont get how can she become top 5,or top 10 even,no covers,one or two campaigns girl be out in 2/3 season

 

[LiranYana]

I really dont see jac lasting more than 2 yrs.i mean just at her work one or two campaigns.she yas no support of any high fashion

Jac has been getting and concentrating on print work lately
she has a better season so far, Jac may venture in commercial modeling the future but definitely will still do high fashion. she still does good campaigns

she may not be a muse or have support from major photographers
but she makes it up for camapigns

Karlie is what 19 now ? she's done major modeling for 4 years now
Karmen impressive and she's getting better and she's still young and has long way to go

Arizona I have second thoughts but she'll have longevity, imo

 

[valliaddict]

I may be wrong, but I really don't see Arizona ever becoming an icon. Her walk is downright painful & her pictures are one note. I think she made such a big splash her first season, that its going to be hard to keep that momentum up, especially when she isn't even good at modelling. I get that people may like her look, but it takes true skill to stay at the top. Think of Raquel Z, she may not be the most beautiful girl ever, but she has mastered the art of modelling. Arizona is overrated. Just because you cut your hair the same length as Anna Wintour doesn't make you a supermodel.

As for Karlie, I like her, but I think she may have done all she can do in her high fashion career. I mean, Galliano is gone from Dior, and she is really getting old at OLDR. I don't see her becoming a muse for any other designers they way Galliano & ODLR repped her. I think her career will go one of two ways: 1) VS route, or 2) Coco Rocha route(occasional obscure modelling & self branding).

Karmen has true icon potential, IMO. She has blossomed later than most girls, and that may be a good thing.

You already know how I feel about Joan :love:

 

[littlekiki]

i didnt mean to insult u but your constant posts about freja got a bit silly.

by the way, how do u even consider arizona, karmen and karlie have longevity? these girls have been around for only a few years. they are not newbies but considering them as having longevity is a bit silly.

I think she means that they will last long in the industry.

 

[milo84]

^^
agree with raquel, she looks quite plain in candids. but her editorial works are stellar. i think that is why she is still on demand.

constance j. on the other hand is a very beautiful girl. but to me, she's still resting on her good looks.

 

[franki]

^^^^ I find jac to be extremely limited in versatility. its unfortunate because she is so stunning. but IMO she is yet to be convincing as anything but a runway and beauty girl. i can't see her as sexy or edgy or grown-up. i feel she has stagnated a bit and i think for that reason her longevity is questionable. i don't see her ever reaching top 5 status, and i think there are newer models who have so much momentum that are just going to overrun her unfortunately.

beauty is her niche for sure.

 

[valliaddict]

^^IDK I think with age comes experience. I don't think Jac knows who she is yet, and so she plays it safe by staring vacantly into the camera. That is why she doesn't get much editorial work. She has the makings of a big time model, but it will take her a while to learn how to convey true emotion.

 

[franki]

^ i agree she will get better with time but the problem is that the industry doesn't wait forever. eg her and karlie were signed to their respective agencies in the same year and i think there is a considerable gap between their developments (note: i prefer jac over karlie, so i dont think i am being biased). sure, karlie is yet to prove longevity, but then there will be the 'next karlie' who will have that huge momentum and be the 'hot new girl' and overtake jac again.

so, IMO, thats why i think that top 5 just won't happen for her, unfortunately. she is loved by her fans yet thats just not translating into her work/demand. :-(

 

[congacon]

of all the new girls, i find karlie to be the strongest candidate to have a long career in the modeling industry bc compared to others karlie has a lot of talent in front of the camera. this girl can pose.

arizona is a very beautiful girl but she is lack of depth.

 

[littlekiki]

^I agree with you. Plus, Karlie is such a sweetheart. She has the whole package and is very versatile.

 

[fonghay]

^I think Karlie will take on the route of Coco Rocha sooner or later if high fashion modeling doesn't work out.At least this girl is smart enough to keep herself on the radar

 

[littlekiki]

I think Karlie has a better chance in remaining in the industry longer than Coco did when she was at the same place Karlie currently is in her career. If that makes sense.

 

[rockangel]

^^completely agree. I think when Lara goes to the icons list the top 10 should look like this:

1) Freja
2) Anja
3) Sasha
Abbey Lee
4) Joan
Karlie
5) Natasha
Arizona
6) Constance
7) Liu
Jac
8) Karmen
9) Sigrid
10) Daphne

See how impartial I was? I'm so proud if myself

I'm almost in agreement with this list ....great work!...finally an impartial tfser!

 

[valliaddict]

Thanks, rockangel

^ i agree she will get better with time but the problem is that the industry doesn't wait forever. eg her and karlie were signed to their respective agencies in the same year and i think there is a considerable gap between their developments (note: i prefer jac over karlie, so i dont think i am being biased). sure, karlie is yet to prove longevity, but then there will be the 'next karlie' who will have that huge momentum and be the 'hot new girl' and overtake jac again.

so, IMO, thats why i think that top 5 just won't happen for her, unfortunately. she is loved by her fans yet thats just not translating into her work/demand. :-(

I think the industry always makes room for a classic beauty like Jac. I predict her fashion career is going to slow down in about two years, then she'll do strictly beauty for a while. When she gets a little older, she will return to fashion better than ever. I know that rarely happens, but I think once she gains some skill, she can be as big as Daria or Natalia. I'm not a die hard Jac fan, but I think I will be in 5 years

 

[Ochi Chernye]

I think Karlie has a better chance in remaining in the industry longer than Coco did when she was at the same place Karlie currently is in her career. If that makes sense.

Huh, what do you mean?

 

[littlekiki]

When Coco was at the same place in her career as Karlie currently is in her career, I find that Karlie seems to have a better chance at lasting than Coco did back then.

 

[valliaddict]

Coco was THE editorial queen of 2007. I miss the US Vogue Coco. I don't like the random Elle & Tatler Coco, if THAT makes any sense

BTW, I'm glad we are talking about something other than Freja & Anja in this thread. Lets see how long that lasts.

 

[alonsoJonathan]

^

Freja Becoming the number one model,will Damage the modeling world
i mean hse is sooo boring,u see her she doesnt seen to be alive she is just sooooo what ever!

i mean can u imagine people outside fashion looking at her as the number one?
if thats how the number one looks can u imagine the rest? that what i will said!!

 

[valliaddict]

@alonsoJonathan- LMAO I hate you right now

@Liranyana- you clearly don't get it.