MDC (Models.com) Rankings

[trikekos]

oh, I just read the post #31, and tell me the models that were on the top 10 in 2006..mmm

I may read some pages back, thank you.

 

[Vinciano]

no offence seriously but they always put the ethnic models higher than the non ethnic models that do much better! sesilee's rank is ridic.honestly! compared with other models who've done much more like maryna for example shes a 20-30..

Her rank is outrageous but I don't think it has to do with her race. MDC have always had a special relationship with Sessilee and I think that has more to do with it than anything. They just like her a lot, and in turn give her an extremely high ranking. I think you get bonus points for showing up to their office and making a video. LOL

 

[miwa]

They moved Sessilee up yet again! It's getting ridiculous. Jourdan moved up, but still lower than Sessilee. On what planet?

Magdalena Frackowiak still hasn't moved. She must have rubbed someone at MDC the wrong way at some point. She's a bonafide top ten at the point.

Really now? The current top "10" girls are:
1. Raquel
2. Natasha & Sasha
3. Lara & Lily
4. Coco
5. Agyness & Anja
6. Anna Maria & Stam
7. Mariacarla
8. McNeil
9. Freja
10. Trentini & Toni

Comparing Magdalena's work to the work of these girls there's no doubt: Magdalena is not nearly top 10 material. And still the under 10 girls deserve that spot before her (see Jourdan, Karlie, Iris, Anna S).

 

[Vinciano]

I'm not even a big Magdalena fan, but I still have to disagree. Magdalena is one of the very top girls on the runway, she's always in editorials and gets her fair share of covers. Some of the girls in the top ten haven't done anything of note in awhile. They need to be dropped/removed. There are girls in the top ten who are semi-retired, and have been for awhile. I don't see the point of having them in a working girl list.

And, I never said there aren't other girls who don't deserve a spot in the top ten too. There are 15 girls in the top 10, so there is obviously enough room for them. Magdalena certainly is competitive with some of the girls you mentioned though.

 

[miwa]

She had what? one Numero, a Vogue Italia (shared with Kasia), a Vogue Russia and a Vogue Germany cover. That's nothing if you compare it with those from the top 10. This is not a style.com list, runway doesn't really count. Agyness only does Anna Sui and House of Holland and yet she is in the fifth place. While I do think that Agyness and McNeil need to be dropped, there are other girls in front of Magdalena that should come in their places.

 

[Edita]

Some of the girls in the top ten haven't done anything of note in awhile. They need to be dropped/removed. There are girls in the top ten who are semi-retired, and have been for awhile

I Agree! For exsample Toni! She hasnt done editorial for a long while & and imo Madga is everywhere present or Eniko.

I like Toni very very much but lets face the truth at the moment she doesnt deserve rang 10 (!!)

 

[modela]

well i actually think that toni deserves her spot , you cant deny the numbers of campaigns she had this season and we have to keep in mind she is still in school , so that explains her lack of editorials probably , she has made a big mark. For me Aggy,caroline, catherine need to be moved down

 

[miwa]

I agree, Toni is probably the model I dislike the most but she does deserve the 10th place.

 

[AriLove]

I agree about Toni but i don't really get Catherine's position at the moment. Even though i really really love her, she doesn't really belong to the top 10, at least not right now. She hasnt done big editorials, except for Numéro, covers and campaigns (except her Narciso perfume ad and an upcoming LV cruise ad) in a while. Freja needs to step in at her place..

 

[Edita]

well i actually think that toni deserves her spot , you cant deny the numbers of campaigns she had this season and we have to keep in mind she is still in school , so that explains her lack of editorials probably , she has made a big mark. For me Aggy,caroline, catherine need to be moved down

Which campaigns? I only know abour Donna Karen & Boss. And its not only about campaigns .. what about editorials? Her last editorial is from Vogue Germany in March (!!). Ok she is still in school but that doesnt count.
You cant consideration of that. Her work counts and if she cant do more work its ok. Then she can do more work when she finish school. But imo rang 10 is not fair compared to the other models who do sooo much!!

 

[Vinciano]

She had what? one Numero, a Vogue Italia (shared with Kasia), a Vogue Russia and a Vogue Germany cover. That's nothing if you compare it with those from the top 10. This is not a style.com list, runway doesn't really count. Agyness only does Anna Sui and House of Holland and yet she is in the fifth place. While I do think that Agyness and McNeil need to be dropped, there are other girls in front of Magdalena that should come in their places.

Runway does indeed count. Some girls have debuted on MDC list before they released a single campaign.

As for Magdalena, guess we are going to have to agree to disagree on that one.

 

[Thanatos]

I agree about Toni but i don't really get Catherine's position at the moment. Even though i really really love her, she doesn't really belong to the top 10, at least not right now. She hasnt done big editorials, except for Numéro, covers and campaigns (except her Narciso perfume ad and an upcoming LV cruise ad) in a while. Freja needs to step in at her place..

I love Cat too, but she didn't book any campaigns the last 2 seasons except for a couple of cruise collections in between, hasn't had a single cover in something like 8 months, and has had an abysmal four show seasons. I don't get why she is still so high.

Agyness should just be off the list completely if you ask me.

 

[Edita]

About Agyness i have to agree

 

[madame_georgiana]

I wonder if Caroline will drop since she didn't get the DG campaign as usual?

 

[agee]

I would think that campaigns would carry the most weight. Eds and covers definitely matter, but they are the means to an end, namely a campaign / contract. Some models who have booked multiple campaigns decline eds or runway shows, or at least don't hustle as hard to book them, or, more likely, the model and her agent are focusing their energies chasing campaigns. Note I am not saying that they are turning down VI and VP covers and only girl eds, and this type of work paves the way for campaigns, but my guess is that one or two key campaigns will trump multiple eds.

 

[modela]

Which campaigns? I only know abour Donna Karen & Boss. And its not only about campaigns .. what about editorials? Her last editorial is from Vogue Germany in March (!!). Ok she is still in school but that doesnt count.
You cant consideration of that. Her work counts and if she cant do more work its ok. Then she can do more work when she finish school. But imo rang 10 is not fair compared to the other models who do sooo much!!

i was talking about the s/s campaigns

*emporio armani
*prada
*hugo boss
*chloe
*fendi
*etro
*Clea de Peau (beautycampaign)
*Versense ( parfume by versace)

 

[WerbowyStegner]

imo Toni deserves #10.. Shes busy with school apparently but still I think if Toni doesn't deserve #10 , then Catherine doesnt deserve her top 10 status. Imo Toni is a star .. And Boss and Donna Karan are major campaigns.. and most campaigns still arent out yet..

 

[Edita]

imo Toni deserves #10.. Shes busy with school apparently but still I think if Toni doesn't deserve #10 , then Catherine doesnt deserve her top 10 status. Imo Toni is a star .. And Boss and Donna Karan are major campaigns.. and most campaigns still arent out yet..

I adore Toni sooo much she is my fav. But lets be fair we must say that she doesnt deserve rang 10- at the moment. If we see some new cover, an ED (!!!) or maybe some new campaign then its ok

 

[madame_georgiana]

Jourdan will surely top Sessilee now she has a Maybelline campaign...

 

[WerbowyStegner]

OMGGGG when did this happen *rushes to jourdans thread*