Personally, I don't see how the old Hollywood aesthetic is sick...
I think with movie stars you are always going to have pictures like that because ultimately the iconography of Hollywood goes back to that as that is a part of the history behind such celebrities. To represent film stars as classic icons themselves is tedious but to borrow from that image in order to represent people as themselves doesn't bother me. This isn't Katie being Gene Tierney or Tom reenacting Gregory Peck, it's simply stylized imagery akin to the old style of photography.
Also I think for these two people this works. I don't think anyone was justifying their image based on these pictures. Quite frankly it would be hard for people to do so given their ongoing antics. I think there was a positive response to the covers in spite of their subjects. You've got two people who have in the course of a couple years become self parodying tabloid pariahs and Solve managed to make them look austere and beautiful. He managed to make me at least forget momentarily their collective bull****. It's an accomplishment as far as I'm concerned.
And yes I still like Tom but god I have to call a spade a spade.