This argument falls completely flat for me because while Anna uses a lot of the same girls repeatedly, this year Vogue US has used twice as many different models than Alt has used at Vogue Paris. In terms of variety, I'd say Vogue US is second only to Italia. There's a lot of opportunity to be in the US edition while Paris sticks to a relatively strict rotation of girls.well, people always complain about alt, but anna uses the same models over and over and over again.
Karlie's editorial with the male athletes is the definition of "hit or miss" for me. I much prefer something like Raquel's editorial by Testino from the last summer Olympics because she is interacting with the athlete in each shot. A photo of Karlie and an athlete standing stock still next to each other? A waste of both of them, in my opinion. Not to mention boring.