Celebs Caught Wearing the Same Outfit - (May 2011 - November 2013)

[LuellaLuella]

When I said I agree I meant with the post above CielDeLit's. I agree about Diane but not Olivia. I think she over-complicated it, though I do agree about the skin-tone comment.

 

[sobriquet87]

Diane. She looks more elegant, but I prefer Alessandra's shoes.
Olivia. It looks great on both of them, but I love Olivia's shoes and clutch.
Plus I like that she wore her hair up.

 

[luckyduck]

It's a tie for me between Diane and Alessandra but definitely Elle in the Marchesa. It's a very youthful dress imo and Olivia's shoes are all kinds of wrong!

 

[Versace-Goddess]

olivia- her details are winning with the dress.

 

[hautechild]

Diane - she manages to make it look not so much like she's an icedancer

Elle - it looks adorable on her and Olivia picked the wrong shoes with the dress and she should know better!

 

[Versace-Goddess]

Diane- the simplicity in her details make it more chic.

 

[lebigt]

Diane Kruger vs. Alessandra Ambrosio in Dolce & Gabbana Spring/Summer 2011

Elle Fanning vs. Olivia Palermo in Marchesa Spring/Summer 2011
zimbio

Diane wins. She nailed it. She's baring a lot of leg, but manages to keep it classy. So statuesque. Adriana - It's the hair.

Elle wins. Age-appropriate, and the lack of accessories elevates the look. Love her hair down - kept it youthful, and added a subtle casual touch. Olivia - poor choice of accessories. Overall, not sitting well with me.

 

[agee]

Diane Kruger vs. Alessandra Ambrosio in Dolce & Gabbana Spring/Summer 2011
I am torn, I like Diane's hair better but I really like Alessandra's shoes. I am not bothered by Alessandra's pose because a) it was a VS event and b) she did other poses. Hmm, based on the pictures posted, I will go with Diane.

Elle Fanning vs. Olivia Palermo in Marchesa Spring/Summer 2011
Elle looks like a little girl playing dress up... oh, wait a minute. I like the dress with Olivia's skin tone and I like her shoes (not sure if they work with the dress though), still I think that I am going to give it to Elle because I think that Olivia is a tad too ornate.

 

[lifeistiffanyblu]

Diane - she adds so much class and elegane to the dress, not tha I dont think Alessandra has any of those as I love her too but the dress looks better on Diane.

Olivia-the colour works with her skin tone without making her look washed out, even though her shoes are so not the right ones for the dress.

 

[Party.in.Paris]

Keira VS Olivia
Because Olivia's outfit is just terrible.

Gaia VS Lea
Because Gaia's figure is more appropriate for this dress.

Diane VS Alessandra
Because even though Ale is taller she has short legs compared to Diane.
I prefer Dianes shoes and she looks classier.

Elle VS Olivia
Because I prefer Elle's shoes and this dress is cuter on her. It does nothing on Olivia.

 

[fantastical]

Diane! it looks so much better on her proportions. I hate when Alessandra wears short dresses because it shows off how stumpy looking her legs are. and also Diane, looks better with the pulled back haire

Elle! because it's such a girly and cute dress that she obviously loves wearing which translates in her posture

 

[myown]

Olivia. I think Elle looked cute, but Olivia was stunning in that dress.

 

[luckyduck]

Selena vs Kellie in Zuhair Murad

people

 

[sobriquet87]

Kelli. She has the curves to pull it off and I love her shoes.

 

[TREVOFASHIONISTO]

both of their hair sucks...neither

 

[LolaSvelt]

Selena looks less vicious because of her shoe choice. I pick her. Ugly dress, though.

 

[meanced]

Selene only because I like her shoes more.

 

[luckyduck]

The dress is too shiny for me, like a disco ball. But I prefer selena, like LolaSvelt because of her shoe choice.

 

[lebigt]

Selena vs Kellie in Zuhair Murad

Selena, hands down. Kelli has WAY too much going on. All the accessories (earrings, cuff, shoes) are too matchy with such a "look at me" dress. The better option would be to tone it down, since the dress speaks volumes on its own, which Selena did well.

 

[TheBlackRose]

^Gotta agree!

So Selena for me. I like the dress with her body more.