No it's understandable. I used to think the same when I was a huge fan of Emily's (still am, just more of a casual one now) but compared to when she first jumped on the scene, she never hit that stride I thought could make her a stand out.She came close when she booked all of those covers and campaigns after her first SI appearance, but it hasn't been the same.
It sounds negative (not trying to be) but she's no Karlie Kloss.
She's got a solid career (no knocking on that) but honestly, I think where Emily is at this point will just be working comfortably. In my opinion she's got a steady contract as one of the main faces for Maybelline, why hustle when you have something that's secure?