MoniqValentino
Active Member
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2013
- Messages
- 1,235
- Reaction score
- 0
This is a joke! JOAN If not dropped in the ranking (should) it should also stay Karlie! models.com is not fair!

Share your thoughts on the... 2025 Met Gala!
MODERATOR'S NOTE: Please can all of theFashionSpot's forum members remind themselves of the Forum Rules. Thank you.
What has Joan even booked lately?! Not one FW campaign if I remember correctly. Makes no sense
This list is a complete joke. Everybody KNOWS Karlie is the No.1 model right now. When Arizona Muse got the EL contract, they quickly moved up her rank. Karlie was No.2 before she got the VS contract and after she got it she's still No.2, WTH?.
No.1 is a completely bull****. Aside from the EL contract, Joan has nothing big under her belt. Campaigns-wise, cover-wise, celebrity status-wise she's behind Karlie. I can see Karlie will soon become an Industry icon, but Joan? not so much.
Joan is not to blame![]()
To be honest, i am not the biggest Karlie fan but her work is mind blowing beautiful. Joan is overrated because of her ethnicity of being the first colored women to do a chanel campaign since Kimora Lee (i believe) etc.
fashioncopious.typepad.comHow Accurate Is Models.com's Top 50 List?
April 16,2011
I might be a bit ignorant, but can someone explain to me how Models.com's Top 50 List:
1- Is tabulated?
2- Accurate it is?
Models.com:From my understanding, the Models.com team is quiet small (5-10 people). So I find it hard that their database is up to date, with accurate information on the hundreds of models in the industry, with their campaigns and contracts. It's got to be quite hard to keep a tab on all this happening.
From the daily call sheets of photographers like Steven Meisel, Mario Testino, Mert n Marcus, Craig McDean, David Sims,Inez and Vinoodh and Steven Klein for clients like US, Italian, French and British Vogue, W, V, i-D, Numero, Bazaar, Pop and Another can be culled a clear message about who are the most wanted models of the moment.
It is also brands like Prada, Vuitton, Chanel, Dior, Calvin Klein, Estee Lauder, Lancome and Maybelline among others who provide the platform that makes stars of models. In an increasingly competitive market, flooded with hundreds of "cool editorial girls", its the campaigns and contracts that are the final index of how crucial a model is at any given moment.
Consequently here are the faces of the future, MODELS.com's Top 50 Working Models listing.
As one The Fashion Spot member puts it:I concur with that, as I my self have seen wrong or un-updated information on the site. And this would reflect the list its self.
Models.com are always wrong about a lot of things so it doesn't mean anything.
For example, currently Catherine McNeil is #24 on the list, while Daphne Groeneveld is at #27. If you have been paying any attention you'll know that Groeneveld has been a whole lot busier over the past year than McNeil. And got more [presumed] prestigious spots.
Also how far into the models time line do they go, to figure this out? Is it monthly, quarterly, yearly?
They do not clarify it.
But let's assume everything is 100% accurate. The next question is how do they tabulate this Top 50 List?
Is it a points system?
- Do campaigns, editorials, covers get a certain amount of points?
- Is one designer worth more than another?
- Is a cover worth more than an editorial?
- Is a campaign worth more than a cover?
- Is one magazine worth more than another?
- Does one photographer get more points than another?
- Is a lookbook worth more than a catalog, or the other way around?
- If so why is one designer or photographer or magazine etc... worth more than another? And how do they decide this?
You get my drift. How things are rated is also not clarified.
Models.com again:I can somewhat go along with this opening paragraph. But the top 50 list is questionable as far as I can tell. Mainly because this contest does not seem to have any rules, to judge things by.
Let's face it. The clients, especially the blue chip ones are the stars of fashion now and it's their choices, selections and bookings that make and break models today.
I'm really just curious about this list, which some in the industry seem to take so seriously. Maybe you can help me understand it better.