Nina Garcia Out at Elle? *Update-She's in at Marie Claire* | Page 4 | the Fashion Spot

Nina Garcia Out at Elle? *Update-She's in at Marie Claire*

I don’t care either for US Elle (UK ELLE is way better) but who doesn't like a bit of drama.

I would like to know who is the editor of US Elle and what the hell are they doing when all this hiring, firing and quitting is going on.

Isn't the editor the "boss" of the magazine? If my staff were quitting left and right and numbers were down, I wouldn't be sitting on my *** I would be finding out what the problem is and fixing it. It sounds like the problem is Joe Zee so the solution would be get rid of him. Doesn't Joe answer to the editor.

If US Elle gets axed would that affect the others especially UK and French?
 
Roberta (Robbie)Myers (sp?) is the editor and cheif of Elle. But I have the feeling that Zee is really running the show now. And I guess Gilles was running it before him. To be honest with you I have hardly ever heard of Robbie before Zee came to Elle.

I'm pretty sure Roberta knows was the problem is. She either is completely fine with that said problem, or Zee isnt allowing her to fix it. Why would she get rid of Zee. She just got him, and Elle made a big stink about getting him. Also with all her staff leaving now getting rid of Zee won't bring them back. Elle is losing their credit, why would those people return to magzine thats losing its power.

I doubt US Elle will get axed. At least not any time soon. There are just too many women who dont want to read Cosmo, but are bored with Vogue. Elle is that middle ground. Unless all those women are okay with only have Harper's to read every month.
 
It does sound like spring cleaning to me. Especially with all the talk about how they can't send their editors to Paris, and somebody posted about how sparse the Elle offices were in NYC... Maybe if they let some people go, they would have enough budget left to hire models that I can actually identify...

And reading the posts from that forum, it seems that Elle had been so divided from the start due to the Anne vs. Nina war. Nina had always been Gilles' favorite, but now that Gilles had been, um, demoted, she has lost her clout, and Anne Slowey (who as per the gossip goes, is much closer to Joe Zee) triumphed. I could figure a couple of high school bitchfights in those posts and neither of them were painted as saints and it appears that both of the were catty, with Nina being a little more cattier; their war must have been pretty divisive. I guess with a key figure gone, people would actually get back to work?

I still have faith in Joe Zee, Elle is still more readable and pretty to me these days than before, although those annoying paragraphs on the cover are, well, annoying and he should really work on that. I still find Elle more relatable than Bazaar and Vogue, if only they had high profile edits and models and photographers that I actually know...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
if only they had high profile edits and models and photographers that I actually know...
But that's not necessarily a bad thing it's good that a high profile magazine is not using the same models and photographers as everyone else.
It's comforting that other photographers are given a chance to showcase their work in Elle magazine.
 
But that's not necessarily a bad thing it's good that a high profile magazine is not using the same models and photographers as everyone else.
It's comforting that other photographers are given a chance to showcase their work in Elle magazine.

I completely agree!!
 
i completely agree yalil! :flower:

and i do believe Elle is trying. They recently had an editorial by Karl Lagerfeld. It wasn't Karl's best work. But it was still Karl. And their recent designer editorials and interviews are good as well.
 
Interesting. ^_^

What Happened With Nina

Apr 14, 2008 @ 12:01pm

A lot of you have been bugging us to talk about Nina Garcia's departure from ELLE.
We knew the weekend would bring a zillion people with a zillion accounts of what happened - and of course it did - so here's a handy guide to get you through the internet rumors and into a short conversation with everyone in your cubicle co-op:

What's False: Everyone agreed that there wasn't any kind of fight, there were no boxes packed in the hallway, or crying interns. In fact, most people used the same word: "quiet."

What's True: Everyone's quick to say that Nina was never around, and rarely seen in her office. Project Runway was the reason to keep her on, which everyone thought would only be for one more season, but after Lifetime bought it, well, that was just a little too long to hang on.

So the big bad story? Nina was making too much money for not doing any actual work related to being a Fashion Director of a major magazine. Guess that's the price of TV stardom.

And there you have it.

Now, more pressing: How will Heidi introduce her during Season 5? Or, will she be in Season 5?

fashionista.com
 
http://www.fashionologie.com/

The newest report is that Nina Garcia has been offered a little more than an outright auf Wiedersehen: The former Elle fashion director can choose to stay on at the magazine as an editor-at-large or contributing editor.

The reason that Nina would accept such a role is so that she could stay on "Project Runway" for another season, since Elle is a confirmed partner for the upcoming season five. However, Elle is not expected to continue its partnership thereafter, when the show transitions to the Lifetime Network for season six. So would Nina really want to accept such a pity position for only one guaranteed season?

She's apparently talking with Harvey Weinstein, who produces "Project Runway," and Bravo about new television projects. Considering that besides Anna Wintour, who inadvertently found public fame with The Devil Wears Prada, Nina is the most publicly recognized fashion editor, it will be interesting to see how she plays her cards.
 
Nina should definitely go to tv. maybe she'll get a show on the style network or E!
 
from fashionweekdaily.com

Nina Garcia may have parted ways with Elle as fashion director, but in lieu of an outright dismissal, Fashion Week Daily has learned that Garcia has been offered a new role at the magazine: editor-at-large or contributing editor.

Should Garcia, whose contract was up for renewal this month, accept this lesser role, she would be allowed to remain on Project Runway for at least one more season. The hit reality series has just started casting for season five, with Elle as a confirmed partner, and will start filming June 8 and premiere on Bravo. According to sources, however, Elle is not expected to continue its partnership with Project Runway once the show transitions over to the Lifetime Network beginning with season six.

NBC Universal, Bravo's owner, recently sued The Weinstein Company, producer of Project Runway over the move.

Elle editor in chief Robbie Myers was unavailable for comment. Anne Janas, senior vice president of corporate communications for Hachette, said over the weekend, "We will have more to say next week. Robbie is not available for comment until then." According to sources, Garcia has not yet committed to Hachette's offer, nor has a final deadline been set for her to make a decision.

Garcia's exit comes at a time when there were no clear indications of her departure. In the midst of several days of nighttime activities, Garcia attended a dinner in honor of Christian Lacroix at the Gramercy Park Hotel rooftop deck Thursday night. On Wednesday night she turned up at the Jeffrey Fashion Cares fashion benefit. However, she was a no-show Tuesday night at a dinner her magazine hosted with Moschino to celebrate Simon Doonan's new book, Eccentric Glamour: Creating an Insane More Fashionable You. Noticeably absent--despite the presence of fellow colleagues Myers, Joe Zee, Paul Ritter, Kate Lanphear, Keith Pollock, and Joan Pailey--Garcia at the time shrugged it off to being in Los Angeles, where on Monday she taped a cameo on "Ugly Betty."

Last March, Garcia went on maternity leave, giving birth to her first son named Lucas Alexander Conrod. Rumors that she would not return to the magazine proved untrue when she came back and was given a monthly fashion column and her visibility and level of authority remained unchanged. Garcia's celebrity spotlight has grown exponentially since she joined the cast of the Bravo reality show "Project Runway" as a judge and penned a book, The Little Black Book of Style, having recently returned from Hong Kong for a promotion at Lane Crawford. Earlier this week, The Weinstein Company, producer of Project Runway announced the decision to move the show from Bravo to Lifetime Television.

Garcia's exit from the magazine is expected to rest months of rumors and gossip over unrest at the fashion title that began when Zee arrived at the beginning of 2007 as creative director. It's no secret that there were ever-increasing tensions between Garcia and Zee--largely reflective of the old guard versus the new guard--where the former saw several colleagues from her heyday leave the company, including art Guillaume Bruneau and style director Isabel Dupré. Since then, Myers has also taken on a more active role on the fashion side and has made several significant changes to the structure of the magazine, including taking international creative director Gilles Bensimon's office and authorizing Carter Smith to replace Bensimon in shooting this and next month's covers.

Not to be outdone, Zee was recently given his own monthly column in Elle, which, by coincidence or not, appears in the front of book ahead of Garcia's column. Zee has also been busy preparing for Elle's new reality show on the CW network called Fashionista. Produced by Tyra Banks and Ken Mok of America's Next Top Model fame, the show follows contestants eager to become a fashion assistant at the magazine. The show will air this summer.
 
from wwd today...

Take Nina Garcia, Elle, "Project Runway," Lifetime Television and Bravo and what do you get? A Gordian Knot of relationships that have to be unwound, rewound, reconfigured and just plain figured out. Yes, as reported on WWD.com Friday, Garcia was let go from her position as fashion director at Elle and, yes, the magazine is now scrambling to find Garcia a place — albeit a symbolic one — on the masthead as editor at large. Why? Because of "Project Runway," which has made Garcia a household name and raised Elle's profile.

It's all a bit of a mess, especially since some Elle staffers have been itching to say "auf wiedersehen" to the editor for years. Sources close to the magazine said Garcia would have been shown the door a while ago, but her rising profile associated with "Project Runway" gave Elle a reason to keep her. And it may do so again.

The hiccup is season five of the program, which was up in the air last week after The Weinstein Co. decided to take "Project Runway" to the Lifetime Network from Bravo because it would be paid more money. Many at Elle assumed that would mean Bravo would likely drop season five — the last the magazine was contracted to be involved in as a partner. But — surprise! — Bravo decided to push ahead and, suddenly, Elle needed Garcia again — just as she needs the magazine.

According to sources close to "Project Runway," Garcia's future with the show depends on her decision to stay at the title. If she chooses to stay on as a contributor, she will serve as a judge on the show through season five. The show is currently holding castings for its season five contenders, and will begin taping this summer. The last episode will air after September's fashion week in New York.

If Garcia completely severs ties to Elle, sources say it will be difficult for her to remain as a judge during season five. But that equally would be a blow to Elle, since finding another editor to replace Garcia for what might be only one season would be a challenge. While fashion news director Anne Slowey has substituted for her on the show several times in past seasons, she is filming her own reality show along with Elle creative director Joe Zee and other staffers, "Fashionista." That show will air on CW in the summer, right around the time "Project Runway" starts its final season on Bravo.

Also up in the air is whether the magazine and other partners will be involved in the show's season six. The magazine is said to have been exploring partnerships with "America's Next Top Model" — whose producers Ken Mok and Tyra Banks are also producing "Fashionista" — and ABC's "Ugly Betty."

As of Monday afternoon, Garcia was still mulling over whether to accept the Elle offer and executives at Hachette Filipacchi Media remained mum on the situation as of Monday afternoon. Since neither Hachette nor Garcia herself would speak about the departure or her future plans, Garcia has hired Rubenstein Associates Inc. to spread word about her accomplishments at Elle during her seven years at the title (since no one at Elle seems to speaking about them). The spokeswoman would not, however, confirm or deny the reports of Garcia's departure from Elle.

A source close to "Project Runway" said the program "is in negotiations with her and hopes to have her back." The program has already signed Tim Gunn and Heidi Klum for the sixth season, and also is in negotiations with the fourth judge, Michael Kors. Meanwhile, several magazines have already shown interest in signing up for "Project Runway" if Elle opts out.

Speculation also has begun as to who will replace Garcia as Elle's fashion director, with rumors that Roopal Patel, Bergdorf Goodman's senior women's fashion director, was heading to the magazine reaching fever pitch. Patel firmly denied it.
 
But that's not necessarily a bad thing it's good that a high profile magazine is not using the same models and photographers as everyone else.
It's comforting that other photographers are given a chance to showcase their work in Elle magazine.

I agree with you actually. But just looking at the Elle threads, their edits do not generate excitement, nobody bothers to scan their edits and post them here. A lot of the avant-garde fashion magazines do have relatively unknown people too and but they are exciting!

But to be fair to Elle, I take it back, they do have very good edits (I just leafed through April's) and photographers (I saw Tom Munro and Jean Baptiste Mondino). At least they are not as boring as Vogue.

I think it is insulting to fire Nina Garcia then offer her another position? Are they messing with her mind?
 
jesus, the more i read about all of this, the more interesting and gossipy it gets! :judge: :shock:
 
Wasn't the drama with Elle and sending editors to the couture shows about a year ago? If so, I don't really see how it is relevant now, although many magazines (whether or not it was reported on) made cut backs with how many people were sent to Paris for those shows. If the numbers at the magazine were in fact down, that would have been all the more reason to bring Joe Zee in. I think he is bringing the magazine back to being really fashionable and interesting. Also, as stated, it didn't really seem like Nina was doing much, aside from her column, which was pretty new and being on PR.
 
Supposedly Elle did not have enough funds to send people to the couture shows. They supposedly only sent Gilles Bensimone (or however you spell his name)
 
I work in the same building as Elle...It's so funny to think of all the drama happening only a few floors up.... :innocent:
 
Oh man i wonder if ELLE is loving all this publicity and i wonder if Garcia will take stay after all under another title....
 

Users who are viewing this thread

New Posts

Forum Statistics

Threads
214,618
Messages
15,268,646
Members
88,715
Latest member
dupa
Back
Top