Prada Pre-Fall 2013 : Amanda Murphy, Irene Hiemstra & Vanessa Axente by Steven Meisel

[GERGIN]

Can't you read? I said "in my opinion" twice. Just like these are your opinion and are not necessarily true.
Vanessa does nothing for me, not in this campaign nor the other two or her covers.

I know it's your opinion, and that was my response to it, lol.

 

[navyvelvetbowtie]

The styling on Vanessa is far better than on Irene's and Amanda's shots, but again she fails to deliver.

The overall outcome of the shots is quite dull, almost amateur. I understand plain backdrops bring out attention on the products advertised, but in this case it makes it look like there wasn't much effort in doing this.

 

[Firefly216]

Irene looks the best, then Vanessa. Amanda isn't doing anything for me.
The actual images are quite boring too

 

[HeatherAnne]

Finally this got interesting, Amanda's shot is EVERYTHING! Vanessa appears very commercial looking here, not impressed by her shots at at all.

 

[navyvelvetbowtie]

Indeed I have to agree, Amanda's shot has some "raw" thing about it, that is quite eye-catching. I maintain my comments on the sloppy overall production though

 

[HeatherAnne]

Yeah, to me it doesn't vibe as a singular campaign. The girls are channeling different moods, and the styling is all over the place. So I guess it's all a matter of which vibe you like best, and to me that's definitely the rawness of Amanda's shot. Irene's shot is a bit awkward with the sexual undertone to her pose. Much as I like Vanessa, her shots look like they should be hanging in a mall somewhere.

 

[DanceFashionista]

Amanda's shot bringing something .. definitely better than Vanessa's!
Posted via Mobile Device

 

[Avogadro]

Why being so mean to Vanessa?
As for me,she is appealing and lovely.

 

[Naen]

I'm all for Amanda's shot - it gives me the most Prada-ish vibe. The rest indeed appears to be more commercial and vanilla.

 

[yee2yy]

I like the campaign, simple beautiful. I think all of them did a great job.

 

[jacquelineo]

Finally this got interesting, Amanda's shot is EVERYTHING! Vanessa appears very commercial looking here, not impressed by her shots at at all.

I totally agree about Vanessa. Amanda steals the spotlight

 

[elle_gb]

I love the styling, it was clean and simple and yet very Prada.

 

[Ortemis]

I don't like it, very catalog like and forgettable.

 

[Moofins]

I won't remember this by next week.

 

[MON]

Boring. I expected something breathtaking

 

[ad31214]

The more I look at Amanda's shot the more she looks kind of lost, like they just shot like five frames of her and this was the one, she doesn't really look like shes trying, but she still looks stunning of course. Vanessa looks amazing but I agree it is a bit commercial, Irene is losing me, the hair (obviously not her fault) is kind of a mess.

 

[alice]

Amanda's shot is perfection.

 

[kewkaw]

Amanda's shot is Perfect

 

[wearesodroee]

One more:

fashiongonerogue.com

 

[ad31214]

Giving me less, her expression seems so cold and distant, but still beautiful nonetheless.