Stella McCartney F/W 2017.18 : Birgit Kos, Iana Godnia & Huan Zhou by Harley Weir | the Fashion Spot

Stella McCartney F/W 2017.18 : Birgit Kos, Iana Godnia & Huan Zhou by Harley Weir

The third shot works, the rest don't. The idea of Harley Weir permanently at Stella McCartney is as ill-fitting as Willy at Prada. They're too static for such diverse brands. I've seen this composition and style before! Stella should, like Tomas Maier, change photographers each season!
 
Is the model on a pile of trash in the second pic?
 
I think the message here is about mass consumption, which is quite a powerful statement but it's not really working out well.

The doodles are immature and the cast is random. Happy for Birgit though, she looks radiant.
 
You're clothes will almost always look better in front of trash. Still not liking it.
 
I get what they're going for, but they really missed the mark.

The casting isn't cohesive. I am happy for Iana, though.
 
Good thing they are already at the dump because that is where this belongs!
 
I actually really like this and I think Harley Weir is a perfect fit for Stella McCartney.
 
I don't really mind this at all, The clothes look great. I find the color strokes quite distract somehow.
 
I usually don't like Stella's work at all and I still think that she's lost her mojo few years ago, but this campaign is so good, especially the video. Even the clothes look way better here than on the runway.
 
I love Stella. I feel like more than a lot of designers today, she really knows what her brand is about.
THis campaign for some reasons is really Stella. She can work with a variety of photographers and still keep her DNA and that is good!

I get the thing, the clothes are beautiful but i'm not that sure about the execution. It's not a bad campaign tho.
 
Love the solo shot of Birgit, the rest doesnt really do it for me though - not a fan of Harley Weir in the slightest
 
Love the solo shot of Birgit, the rest doesnt really do it for me though - not a fan of Harley Weir in the slightest

Same here, I'm positively fed up with this entire clique of new wave photographers. That said, I liked Harley's past campaigns with Natalia because it was better conceived. This one, not so much.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I like this but it would be much better without the random lines. I get the idea but it just looks stupid.
 
I hate the MS Paint doodles around the models. It's neither imaginative nor witty and looks like a mess, even without all the garbage in the background.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

New Posts

Forum Statistics

Threads
214,435
Messages
15,261,678
Members
88,430
Latest member
SadiaBabyBear
Back
Top