review from bwgreyscale boards...
BEST EDIT: 'cameo' dusan reljin shoots lisa cant, vlada & elena
bagucci in lustrous silken Victorian formal wear. katie mossman styled the clothing, and the compositions here are breathtaking. each resembles a Flemish [ver meer, van dyck] portrait or mid-19th century studio photo [a la nadar but in color]. this might be the best lisa cant has ever looked to me. at last her doll-like frozen expression finds its best placement. vlada also is stunning, akin to emina's best work-- the sexy yet placid eastern european brunette, thin, ethereal, angelic & untouchable.elena bagucci might be the most beautiful in this edit. an ivory complexioned eastern european who looks like a blue eyed cecelia chancellor from an aristocratic family. in fact, elena is one of the most aristocratic looking models Ive seen since, say anne v or roos VB. these ultra-luxe looks are amazing, in jewel tones of azure violet, ruby amethyst & sapphire. prada- val- ralph- gucci - armani- dior- missoni. remember roversi's shadowy, anachronistic W edit a few months back, gemma etc? that was great [to me anyway] but this is even better. each pic is like a set piece portrait in a Dutch oil painting, perfect & timeless. among my fave reljin edits ever in W. far & away the highlight of this issue. rating 9+ of 10. lisa cants best work to date & elena & vlada are just as great.
EDIT: 'saturday night' by david sims. models:ilona kuodiene, amy
findlayson, kurstin beaver, elaine fonseca, roc montandon,, arian
laste, shaun haugh, styled by alex white. interesting edit. very english, very 1959 teddy boys/kitchen sink drama, bedsit edit. lots of charged emotional romantic & near-violent storylines, pomaded hair, 50s dresses. superb pics lots of atmosphere. models effective english actors for these roles but I would have preferred 'marquee' famous 2005 models. still impressive & worthy edit for theatrical, period piece ambition. rating 7.25 of 10.
EDIT: DIOR retrospective. images: from debut collections feb-march
1947. ingrid bergman in 'indiscreet' 1957 [the most beautiful screen goddess ever? very possibly]. galliano's hot cream suit 2005. jos baker 1956 [WOW!!]. dietrich in 'stagefright' 1950 [TRIPLE WOW!!!]. pat o'reilly 1957. From dior's bow in 1947 to galliano's extraordinary couture show last week, is there any doubt that Dior is one of the most creative, elegant, sophisticated & impressive fashion brands & artistry ever? No. rating 8.5 of 10.
COVER/EDIT: 'holmes sweet holmes' katie holmes by michael thompson, styled by alex white. cover is best image. 2 lame pics inside. didnt read rbt haskell's feature yet.this is not the katie holmes edit we'd like to see. for thompson, extremely disapointing. photo rating: 2.5 of 10 mainly for fair cover.
EDIT: ewan macgregor shot by dan winters. 2 portraits show how lame
thompsons kat edit is. Ewan looks so much hotter & more intelligent
than kate here.
* geoff beene remembered by rbt haskell. 3 pager appreciation of 1 of
most talented steadfast & important US fashion talents ever.
ADS:
calvin klein 4 pg. (natalia)
bottega w/turly
chanel w/daria
marcel marongiu w/caroline winberg
calvin klein obession night w/gemma
prada w/gemma
armani 4 pg. (erin wasson)
dior (kate)
ysl (daria)
cavalli w/poly, maria carla, lily d.
bcbg w/stam
oscar w/eugenia
neiman marcus w/emina
etro w/polina
akris w/maria dvrinik
fendi w/carolyn murphy
burberry w/kate
marc jacobs w/kristen mcmenamy
piazza sempione w/tasha tilberg
diesel w/ana beatriz
michael kors w/erin wasson
VERDICT: STRONG ONE THUMBS UP. For Reljin, Sims & Dior edits alone, this mag is a must-have. The clothes models & compositions in Reljin edit are among best set pieces in W in 2005. These 3 girls are particularly beautiful & Reljin/White's settings present that perfectly. Sims' kitchen sink drama is a bit wearing yet the compositions styling & acting is successful dramatically. Intertesting counterpoint to picture perfect/Flemish Reljin story. Dior retro is great, as is james turrell's neon pool & winters' macgregor portraits. the social & shopping stuff was a little lighter than usual but cant complain about suzy nor the sharp party pics. On an aesthetic / consumer basis, the ads were great to see, august is suddenly 'the new september' for a lot of labels' to debut fall ads, and there were some great ones incl natalia, turly, daria, gemma, polina, winberg. basically if you're a euro-centric US fashionista like myself, this august W is essential, and ideal for the beach, as cool late afternoon breezes hint at golden autumn sunsets, beyond the east end beaches & potato fields. pass the banana boat, thanks. see you in september. I LOVE "W"!!