Gay City News
ABOUT TOWN: 1 Night, 1 Diva, 3 Roles
By: DAVID NOH
10/02/2008
Email to a friend
Post a Comment
Printer-friendly
[FONT=arial,helvetica]
Christie Brinkley was easily the most beautiful star at the September 22 opening gala for the Met's 125th season.
WILD1/ PR PHOTOS [/FONT]
Real glamour, so essential to, but, really, so rare in opera these days, held definite sway at the gala for the 125th Metropolitan Opera season on September 22. Renée Fleming, as she was promised by the former Joe Volpe regime, ruled as star of the evening, singing scenes from "La Traviata," "Manon," and "Capriccio" (respectively gowned by Christian Lacroix, Karl Lagerfeld, and John Galliano), the first time in Met history that such an honor was accorded to one woman.
Such privilege has definitely stirred envy among certain rival Met sopranos (one of whom recently remarked, "I want Renee's career!") as well as that inexhaustible anti-Fleming claque who never tire of deriding her, say, for the jazzy liberties she's sometimes taken with the repertoire.
Callas and Teresa Stratas may have been more dramatically intuitive actresses than Fleming but, for sheer musicality and lustrous sound, I'd like to know what other living soprano could have pulled off the feat of these highly different roles in three languages. She was rendingly poignant in the second act of "Traviata," which sits perfectly on her voice; deliciously seductive and then impassioned as "Manon"; and in "Capricccio," possessed a profoundly moving sense of burgeoning self-discovery, chic to die for in a blonde pageboy and Galliano Deco wrap and simple black sheath and gloves that echoed Rita Hayworth's "Gilda," which in turn was inspired by John Singer Sargent's portrait of "Madame X."
Lacroix's costumes were gorgeously lighter-than-air and in the grand, unashamedly balls-out 19th century tradition of gala diva-wear (of course, Violetta would wear chiffon and a diamond parure in the country), but Lagerfeld rather phoned in an almost drably simple dix-huitieme number that faded right into the grayish color scheme of the set.
[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, Sans Serif][SIZE=-2]Advertisement[/SIZE][/FONT]
The Times' Anthony Tommasini proudly -- and stupidly, I think -- announced his ignorance of fashion (i.e., costuming) in his review, totally missing the crucial point that Manon here should be the absolute Queen of Parisian fashion, but in this venerable Jean-Pierre Ponnelle production, with its anachronistic mix of Rococo and Empire styles, Lagerfeld gave her the oldest-looking dress on the stage.Â
There were gowns galore in the audience, as well -- everywhere you looked, on a plethora of stars. It was the kind of night where, if you blinked, you missed Faye Dunaway or Jane Fonda (who left after the first act). Rufus Wainwright, John Lithgow, Helen Mirren, Julianna Margulies, Blythe Danner, Christina Baranski, Vera Wang, Barbara Walters, and supermodels Liv Tyler and Helena Christensen (in a typically everything-but-the kitchen-sink gown by escort Zac Posen) were there, but the most beautiful woman present had to be Christie Brinkley, looking every inch the triumphant messy-divorce survivor, in a strapless, skintight Jacques Fath-esque sheath, accompanied by her adorable little son.
Intermission was spent among Fleming's entourage, which included her best friend from college, Sue Shardt, who told me the diva had spent the day dressing her up for the night, in a borrowed Vivienne Westwood gown and Han Feng shawl. When I asked if, as music students at SUNY Potsdam, she could have envisioned her pal's future, said, "Maybe not on this scale, but Renée was always singing beautifully, even by herself, in the middle of a field."
Fleming's personal stylist, the legendary Freddie Leiba told me, "I got involved with her about six years ago. Before that, I don't think she had much interest in fashion. She liked those architectural things by Miyake, but with her now, I'm inspired by Maria Callas, who was the best-dressed opera star of her time. For tonight, the designers sent us their sketches six months ago for approval and there were certain tweakings."
Leiba, part Chinese-Trinidadian, moved to London at a young age and then New York, where he fell in with the Warhol crowd and worked for Interview magazine with artists like Richard Bernstein and Ara Gallant.
"All of them dead. I'm the one that's left," he observed and, when I asked him his opinion of those other, over-blown celebrity stylists -- some with reality TV shows of their own -- now thriving in the very career which he originated, he sniffed, "It's all self-promotion, with them putting themselves forward as much as the client. I don't approve. I'm now working on a new fashion magazine with the New York Observer, which will feature Renée."Â
Upstairs, on the Grand Tier, Martha Stewart was mixing up a special Fleming cocktail for mezzo Susan Graham, doing diva handmaiden-HD TV hostess duty for the live telecast and, as we left the theater, we were treated to samples of "La Voce," Fleming's new perfume, also debuting that night. Quel freakin' nuit!
Composer John Kander, an absolute opera-lover himself, told me that "Capriccio" was one of his favorites, for its theme of which is most vital, the music or the words? He fondly recalled glorious productions with Simon Keenlyside and the late Jerry Hadley, and observed, "What incredible pressure this must be for Renee."
I asked Kander about the last of the four musicals in his trunk written with the late lyricist Fred Ebb and the possibility of it, like the other three, getting a post-Ebb production. "That's 'Minstrel Show," he said, "and we're working on a workshop of it. As for Chita Rivera in 'The Visit' coming to New York after our very successful DC run, well, do you have $2 million?"Â
Funnily enough, I was asked that same question later that night by York Theatre's James Morgan, when I inquired as to the possibility of his enchanting revival of the 1976 musical "Enter Laughing" transferring to Broadway. Run, don't walk to this show, which just got extended, as Josh Grisetti, 26, gives one of the greatest comic performances I have ever seen as an aspiring Bronx actor (read writer Carl Reiner), and, as pure icing, the great George Irving, 85, reprises his original role with magisterial comic delivery, especially on the ribald classic, "Butler's Song."
I asked Irving how many times he's sung this and he said, "I've lost count. They have me doing it at weddings, bar mitzvahs, funerals, you name it!"
The entire production is cast and directed to loony perfection, and the cloud of musical comedy bliss I was on got extended when I caught Paper Mills' "Oklahoma" on Sept. 21. Call me xenophobic, but there are certain shows that need to be directed by an American (especially after the hapless recent Brit-helmed productions of "Fiddler on the Roof," "Company," and "Catered Affair"), and James Brennan (responsible for last season's winning "Kiss Me Kate") instilled it with a youthful verve and randiness that made this warhorse look like a fresh filly again.
Brynn O'Malley was the best Laurey I've ever seen, a real feisty country miss, with belt and lyric high notes, far from the buttery blandness of Shirley Jones in the 1955 film or the 2002 revival's Josefina Gabrielle, that triple threat who couldn't sing, dance, or act. Adam Monley (Curly) and Andrew Varela (a very sexy, sympathetic Jud) made juicy romantic rivals, while Brian Sears brought true Tennessee charm to Will Parker and Megan Sikora was a hilariously horny Ado Annie.
While not quite as ecstasy-inducing as these shows, "The Marvelous Wonderettes" may likely outrun both of them for, in its way, this '50s-60s jukebox musical is as easily crowd-pleasing as "Mama Mia." The storyline about a high school girl group and their reunion may be inane, but there's no gainsaying the considerable vocal talent onstage.
Farah Alvin did a bang-up "Mr. Lee," Bets Malone dropped her airhead comic voice to growl out a very respectable "Respect," and Beth Malone had major pipes as well as a Cheri Oteri-like comic rambunctiousness on "It's My Party." As long as there are any four young actresses in New York who can really sing this profusion of beloved pop standards, this show may enjoy as long a stay as that mediocrity which preceded it at the Westside Theatre, "I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change" (12 years!).
Max Ophuls' "Lola Montez" (1955), which is at The New York Film Festival and subsequently being revived at Film Forum (Oct. 10-30) in a spectacularly restored 35mm print, has been hailed by some as the greatest film of all time. Re-seeing it after many years, this critic begs to differ -- it's not a patch on real Ophuls masterworks like "The Earrings of Madame De," "Letter from an Unknown Woman," or "Caught."
Although visually stunning, the script is airlessly clever, cursory, and completely lacking in emotional depth -- but the real problem is its star. Martine Carol, the pudding-faced French sexpot Ophuls was forced to work with, totally lacks the charisma or sensitivity that an actress like Vivien Leigh, playing another historical seductress, Emma Hamilton, in "That Hamilton Woman," had in such spades that, in a matter of seconds, anyone succumbed.
Even Carol's costumes, which, in any other Ophuls film, would have been sublime, as done by Marcel Escoffier (also responsible for some of the monstrosities Joan Sutherland wore in opera) instead of Ophuls' usual, brilliant collaborator, Georges Annenkov, are pedestrian when not downright vulgar. Ergo, the film is like a beautiful setting with a paste gem at its center, to be seen for the extraordinary circus framing device -- which must have influenced Bob Fosse's "Cabaret" -- but definitely something to be puzzled over afterwards in the crisp autumn air.
Equally visually amazing, Albert Lewin's "Pandora and the Flying Dutchman" (1951) is also being shown in a restored print at the Film Festival (October 10, introduced by Martin Scorsese). I remember when they revived it in Paris all summer long, years ago, and I begged my friend, the late fashion designer Patrick Kelly, to go with me. "No, child," he said. "Once was more than enough. Let's catch the restored 'New York, New York,' instead."
I now know what he meant, but you should definitely treat yourself to this utterly mad, Technicolor hot fudge sundae, a reworking of the famous legend, starring James Mason at his most sexily brooding and, as she was known at the time, "the most beautiful animal in the world," Ava Gardner, so luscious here to make you feel drugged just looking at her.
Contact David Noh at [email protected].
©GayCityNews 2008