If I were to judge her on anything, it would be the fact that she has Beyonce as her music. I've seen a lot of people bashing her lately and I think it's all, for the most part, undeserved. She's a gorgeous girl with a really bright future ahead of her, I'm sure. Those that judge her on personality outside of this thread are ridiculous; this isn't America's Next Top Model, we aren't going to see her giving interviews on Extra!. A great personality is certainly a plus, but on the other hand, it doesn't detract from her ability as a model. She's good at what she does, period.
I should also note that if I was on the cover of US Vogue at 16, I'd probably be a little full of myself, too.