superior preferance by loreal has very nice ash tones, as well as that new natural match. in fact, I AM OBSESSED with the natural match dye. it stays in your hair unbeliEVABLY LONG and the colors are really nice! but a note, the colors tend to be a bit darker than you see on the box, so opt for a shade lighter.
garnier is, in my book, the devil of hairdye. crappy colors that dont stay in for more than one wash. my older sis uses it and i keep telling her to stop wasting her money!