Melfreya, you were nice enough to ask my thoughts on the movie. Don't worry, I
hate spoilers!
I'm a big, big movie fan. So I was dying with anticipation for Black Swan. The only problem is, I wish I didn't read so damn much about it.
I think I'd be more blown away if I didn't know what I was getting into. My problem is, in my excitement, I read way too much, so I knew exactly what I was getting into.
You seem to be like me, absorbing all the information about the film that you can, so maybe it is too late for you. If you want, you can stop reading here and go in as fresh as you can!
Here are my thoughts:
The movie is super intense, graphic, and trippy.
Natalie is exquisite in the movie. Natalie can be bad, but when she's good, she's very good. I think she just flourishes under a superior director (Aranofsky, Mike Nichols) under the right direction she is just stunning. She is subtle in this part, but so damn good. You see how much commitment she put into this part and it is impossible to not be impressed.
If you saw The Wrestler (I wasn't too impressed with that -- Black Swan is a better film) you'll notice a lot of parallels. People practically killing their bodies for their art.
I said in Mila's thread, I wish her and Winona's parts were much bigger, this is definitely Natalie's movie. Winona is
hardly in it (terrible for people who grew up in the 1990's!) and while Mila's part is substantial, what with so many critics salivating over her I expected it to be so much bigger!
The film has a lot of eroticism, a lot of interesting camera works and tricks, and
some graphic scenes but not a lot.
It's a very unique film that can't really be put into a genre.....
I'm still absorbing it, the imagery and themes stay with you for a long time.
All in all (it's still so fresh in my mind, but I'm trying to be as distant from it as I possibly can) for me, it's a 3.5 or a 4 out of 5... I'm still indecisive...
Some cool things the movie does (without spoiling)
- Makes an 'art house' type film kind of mainstream
- Makes a 'horror' film not gruesome, but kind of mainstream (it's a horror film that is not too horrific, you know what I mean?)
- Makes a ballet film kind of mainstream.....
I think in this it is a great accomplishment.
More interesting things:
Winona's character's life parallels with her own actual life... same with Natalie.
Natalie, Mila, and Vincent's characters all parallel characters in Black Swan.
Trippy huh? The more I think about this film, the more I realize it accomplishes.
For Aranofsky fans, Black Swan for me, is the easiest of his films to watch, and the one I most liked.