never really found Clare to be an edgy designer. She churned out decent, wearables at Pringles then pretty, girly, feminine clothes at Chloe but never edgy.
But i can tell she is feeling she needs to be "edgy", perhaps due to her predecessor, doing gothic, dark moods clothing (although that is also not exactly edgy edgy...) so she does what she is doing now, and it failed miserably.
I think she should stop trying to be what she isnt, and do what she does best, and create a new identity for Givenchy. But how does she reinvent the brand?
The Haute Couture is laughable but forgiven given she is a novice, but she wanted to do this, alongside the menswear....so who is to be blamed?
Menswear, by the way, is really a big disaster. I have never felt the urge to walk into a Givenchy store ever since she took helm..