When the MDC rankings were relevant I'd say that Bella wouldn't be as high due to the fact that her success is very new. Gigi & Kendall would be top 15 or so but they'd probably have the top 2 as Lexi and then Anna. They'd probably put Lexi above Anna because she's a Miesel muse and that carries a lot of weight. Unless my suspicion that after Joan, Lindsey was their #1 girl because she was in the top 50 for another year then moved to the Indistry Icon list followed by Andreaa who served the next year as their #1. In that instance Anna would be the current top girl.
The new supers list is horrible because you cannot rank a single one of those girls above the likes of Amber Valleta, Carolyn Murphy, and Helena Christensen who are bonafied legends. The criteria listed would also make a serious case for Angela and Carmen to be legends considering they both have over 15 years of constant blue chip work but at the least it would put them no lower than new supers. Karolina would also be on the new supers list based off the stated criteria. There is no way that anyone on the new supers list should be listed there with the exception of Daria, Karen, Liya, and Natalia. There's a case to be made for girls like Doutzen, Laeticia, Natasha, and Sasha. The rest of the girls on the list simply don't have the range. It used to be unless you were the top 2, you'd be on the top 50 list for years. Erin, Julia, Stam, and Natasha spent YEARS in the top 50, specifically top 5 before moving because they never nabbed a top 2 spot.