Ooooh I follow a youtube guru that LOVES pale pink lipgloss.. I have almost all her recommendations. Here goes!
NYC Tinted Lipbalm in Sugar Coated. Love this stuff! A bit messy to put on but moisturizing and very pale pink on.
Rimmel Lipgloss in East End Snob. This has been my HG lipgloss since middle school I believe. Smells good and very pigmented. I can wear it by itself but it looks good over any lipstick too. Shimmery pale pink.
NYX lipgloss in Sweetheart. Very similar to East End Snob. Comes on light milky pink, very pigmented.
Revlon lipgloss in Pink Whisper. One of my absolute faves! Comes on really glossy, and the perfect pale pink.
ELF lipgloss in Pink Kiss. Cute pale pink! Very sticky. Packaging sucks though. Worth more than a $1 IMO though.
For those of you that like NARS Turkish Delight, I heard that Victoria Secret lipgloss in Innocent is a dupe for it.
Also the NYC Tinted Lipbalm in Sugar Coated is supposedly a dupe for a very pretty milky pink similar to MAC's Cremesheen in Boy Bait