Okay, so I was just watching the Daily Show, and they had a guy wear a green knit poncho as a joke. I looked at him very closely, and I couldn't imagine any way I could like the look. I imagined it in black, a cool fabric, edgy cut...still just doesn't work in my mind. I have nothing against feminine stuff, but to me it's feminine to the point of just looking a bit silly no matter what. But if you want to wear one in a fun, whimsical way, go for it. If you just dressed up really wildly and crazily, then threw on a poncho...