Nearly two years down the line and I still don't get the appeal of Mica Arganaraz.
I definitely get why he seems to like Mica in that she's sort of who you'd get if you combined Omahyra Mota and Caroline Ribeiro (two of his go-to girls during his Gucci/YSL days) but like Benn said above, I don't like that she's almost never transformed by anyone. Yes her natural look works, but the entire idea of a model is that she (or he) becomes a bit of a chameleon. If she'd been "Tom Ford-ed" up a bit more with slicker hair or more dramatic makeup and then thrown into the heady, witchy sort of scene she's in I think it would've had more impact. As she is she doesn't quite become the physical embodiment of what you smell when you spray the perfume.
Not a fan of that fake fog/smoke thing... whatever that bad photoshop pretends to be, it looks VERY fake, totally against nature, light should hit the whole set the same way (here it hits her face very different from the rest of her body, and magically, her face the only part where we don't have this foggy effect at all, 'cause fog behaves like that with models in real life of course ). If you're gonna go for it, do it good and believable. Posing is great, it's interesting enough. It could have been a great picture without the unnecessary effect, it ruins the whole thing making it look fake and dirty.
I think it’s meant to look fake-y— like a surreal painting, with the veil of smoke being her adornment, cloak, etc. It’s Nick Knight, so that brand of artificial, digital accent is acceptable to me. Maybe not the best concept for a Tom Ford campaign though.
I think what Phuel is saying, ultimately, is that Nick Knight's entire aesthetic isn't based on realism at all. His work is proudly artificial and deliberately produced/manipulated looking, to the point that sometimes it really does veer into surreal or impressionistic territory.If what you saying is what crossed their minds... well, it's not really evident they where going for surreal. Tim Walker is surrealism, this looks like they really wanted to make it look it real, but the amount of smoke-effect on her shoulder is hilarious next to her clean face, which is just a few centimeters away. I can't help but feeling someone accidentally rubbed charcoal on the original image and messed it up. I'm surprised Trey Laird was the art director since he did a very good job with Cara's version.