US Vogue September 2008 : Keira Knightley by Mario Testino

[Handbag Queen]

Awful cover. Doesn't look like an autumn cover, colors-wise, at all. Her hair looks horrible. A true mess.

 

[mikel]

The previews look very very good!

 

[Miss Dalloway]

I just love that Klein editorial, finaly they let him shot something different than the robot inspired fashion, and i loveeee how dark it is specially for US Vogue.I guess i will have to just rip off the monstrosity of a cover but it will be done with pleasure.

 

[Simera]

Wow that cover is awful.
But at Isabeli being in an editorial!

 

[mikel]

The cover is indeed very bad.

 

[Les_Sucettes]

I can't stand Caroline, she's bland bland bland. I also do not like Isabeli she always has a "I'm a b*tch" face, soften up girl!
I'm only curious to see Anna.
I actually like Keira but she looks horrid in that pic, although the colours are nice.

Definitely not an issue to buy.

 

[Humperz]

thanks for the scan but im disappointed with the styling and kiera looks strange
the clothes are just layered on and her small frame doesnt support the heavy (what i think is velvet) blouse and the rest just goes on to sicken me. For those reasons i think this cover shoot is sub standard and not worth september vogue, the same month as my birthday!!

dont get me wrong i want to like it, but i just cant.

 

[Fiercification]

Well Trentini/Elgort ed and Klein's ed (no surprise) look great, but I'm so disappointed they couldn't throw a black model in there

 

[LolaSvelt]

I can't help but laugh at her hair. Her face makes up for it, though. Poor Keira, I prefer the other US Vogue cover.

 

[Miss Dalloway]

^^Her face is equally bad, come on she is way more beautiful than that.

 

[LetThemEatCake]

Seriously, who was the hair stylist? She looks like a newborn ape.

 

[Miss Dalloway]

^^

 

[iluvjeisa]

I'm kind of shocked that the editorial content looks so good. The Trentini, Sasha and Klein eds look promising.

However, the Amber/Kirsty ed looks unimaginably boring. If you're going to cast two big name gorgeous girls, why not do something amazing?

Yes, I'm a bit shocked as well...I'm wondering if it's just *alix*'s flawless taste - picked out the very best shots - but I'm seeing better images out of that bunch than out of oh, say, 3 regular issues. It's funny, the last issue wasn't too bad either, once you came to terms with that the cover was awful....

 

[112fan]

how is keira currently relevent enough for a september vogue cover??

 

[agneslo]

^ as long as it's relevant enough for Anna, she will be there.

 

[LolaSvelt]

Seriously, who was the hair stylist? She looks like a newborn ape.

 

[indie]

Actually, I think the hair and the make-up are the best things about the cover...

Klein's ed looks intresting, thanks for the reviews and scans so far!

 

[iluvjeisa]

Has there been any changes to the editorial team lately?

 

[MeMe7]

that cover is horrible , what did they do to her hair

 

[nyc_art_style]

There is way too much text. Keira's hairstyle makes her look like a victim of a bad perm. and she doesn't suit balenciaga. it's a shame because keira is capable of making a good cover picture. but her personality is dull dull dull.

editorial wise, caroline is nice but there is no reason for her to be in two editorials. and there are no black models. and i'm tired of Amber.

editorials look good though.