Meisel's editorial is good, I really like the effects. The only problem is that without them it would have been a terribly boring ed. I wouldn't mind some variation in the shooting angles... I don't know, a bit of more creativity.
But anyway I have no problem with using all the techniques you have at your disposal to make an editorial interesting, so as long as it is visually interesting, everything's fine.
I find the cover incredible, and Roversi's ed is beautiful too, as always.