the setting does a lot for contextualizing these clothes and making them seem part of a cohesive whole, which really drags up the more awkward pieces, but the modeling and the color correction kill this. the treatment of light and shadow makes the images look flat and the clothes lose a lot of their textural detail, and the models need like two cups of cold brew each and direction of any kind. the silver dress which is to me the closest thing mcgirr has had to a hit feels especially poorly served by this. it's not the worst picture, but it feels very indistinct and the photo of the model wearing it on the runway is still the more powerful image of that garment, which shouldn't be the case for a piece they're pushing as a star.