Seeing as I currently own one pair of shoes, and a few more bags: I'd say I'm a bag girl. I'm stunned by the idea of having even 10 pairs of shoes.. 3-4 is about my ideal. But then I don't like to wear heels, and for most of the year (damn Scandinavian climate) I can't wear flats either, which I prefer.
Bags, on the other hand, are rather appealing.