Cocteau Stone
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Feb 12, 2022
- Messages
- 1,976
- Reaction score
- 4,850
This is better than her debut. Much better. But there’s still something off about it. I get the sense that there’s people whispering in Burton’s ears telling her what to do design wise to keep Kering happy. I don’t know but it feels forced in many ways.
What makes this apparent is the disparity and awkwardness in the clothes, styling and music. Many pieces reek of knock offs, but knock offs of notably memorable designs (the YSL low cut skirt, Alaia perforated fabrics, Ferre white shirts) “disguised” with Givenchy “twists” to add social media traction. Then the styling of some of these is really off… the plethora of swim/body suits, all the show jewellery, awkward shoe choices that some of the models are really struggling with and the constant look repeats. With the music (which I think is the best part of the show) is a McQueen redux, with the use of Public Image Ltd and the classical doesn’t match the collection. I’m really lost with this but I’m not offended.
Something is afoot here that is more behind the scenes. The design team and the suits have made for a confusing meddling. I can’t say Burton is a strong designer outright from an independent level, I don’t think she has the strongest vision at large to really support herself unless she fully commits. She’s a great tailor and knows construction. Identity wise, she benefited strongly working at a house like McQueen to help with the narrative and the team/s there would also have been a great support. Her at Givenchy seems like an ideal fit but the dynamic is very different. I’m glad it’s no longer MW, but it’s starting to feel like another CWK case of mistaken identity and vision.
What makes this apparent is the disparity and awkwardness in the clothes, styling and music. Many pieces reek of knock offs, but knock offs of notably memorable designs (the YSL low cut skirt, Alaia perforated fabrics, Ferre white shirts) “disguised” with Givenchy “twists” to add social media traction. Then the styling of some of these is really off… the plethora of swim/body suits, all the show jewellery, awkward shoe choices that some of the models are really struggling with and the constant look repeats. With the music (which I think is the best part of the show) is a McQueen redux, with the use of Public Image Ltd and the classical doesn’t match the collection. I’m really lost with this but I’m not offended.
Something is afoot here that is more behind the scenes. The design team and the suits have made for a confusing meddling. I can’t say Burton is a strong designer outright from an independent level, I don’t think she has the strongest vision at large to really support herself unless she fully commits. She’s a great tailor and knows construction. Identity wise, she benefited strongly working at a house like McQueen to help with the narrative and the team/s there would also have been a great support. Her at Givenchy seems like an ideal fit but the dynamic is very different. I’m glad it’s no longer MW, but it’s starting to feel like another CWK case of mistaken identity and vision.