I hesitate to call this an "Editorial Fail" but it's not very good. The picture with the white ball is the only one that gives a glimpse of what this could have been. The only promising thing is that as bad as I think these pictures are, I&V are the ones that did them. If she made a good impression, maybe this will open up the door to more opportunities of doing more work (hopefully higher quality work) in the future.
I also think the iD editorial was mediocre. It looks just like the Vogue Russia editorial, and I didn't like that. I think it's her poses that don't make either of those editorials work for me.