It's clear the Vitale guy is obsessed with 80's gay iconography, the mustache hunky guy image looking like it's coming straight from a safe for working segment of Colt magazine / TitanMen website. That guy could be mistaken for David Anthony's son (search at your own risk lol).
The main point most people from the fashion pack / people praising the current creative direction are missing is that Versace made its breakthrough as an cultural icon / symbol exclusively thanks to the 90's: the supermodels, the drama, the over the top glamour, the tackiness and opulency. Of course the 80's collection Versace helped the brand gain popularity and relevancy in the fashion conversation but no way it would have turned in a fashion / culture powerhouse it is without the collections from the 90's.
Versace to the average customers (the ones actually spending) is Linda Evangelista in a fluo colored vinyl minidress and Naomi Campbell in a leopard studded leather jacket, not this watered down version of Versace Jeans Couture and Istante by Gianni Versace.