I hope a vote is required and I hope the board members have a heart...and while I certainly understand this is a business, I would hope they would understand that Alessandra needs more than 3 collections to prove herself (although I wholeheartedly think she has ALREADY proven herself worthy).
I also think Alessandra for Valentino would have been a smart move for the long term...because she really is true to the ideas of Valentino, therefore satisfying the old customer, but she's made it more youthful which will eventually bringing in new customers. But because of the economic situation we are in, there really isn't a lot of spending going on therefore limiting the potential numbers of new Valentino customers. If the board and CEO's would realize this, they would understand that after this economic crisis is eased, a whole new Valentino customer base will arise.
Someone like Giambattista is like a bandaide...he's not going to solve the financial troubles Valentino might be facing right now (although I can hardly assume they're desparate)...he'll bring Victoria Beckham with him and she'll wear Valentino to premiers, blah blah blah, and Valentino will be the same as it always was and no new customers will be drawn in.