Calgary Herald
High Noon, 9/11 and generation X
Bob Friedland, For The Calgary Herald
Published: Thursday, September 11, 2008
Bear with me. I know better than you what it is like to have an old geezer tell you that your generation has lost its way. I am, after all, a boomer.
I was chatting with a generation X co-worker a few weeks ago. He is a fine young man of above average intelligence, with two university degrees, and a secure future in government as a middle manager. Let me call him, "Jr."
I had made an allusion to the classic motion picture, High Noon. Jr., did not get it. Now, High Noon, was always more than just a movie. It is one of the great central myths of American men of U.S. President George W. Bush's and my generation.
Email to a friend
Printer friendly Font:
In the movie, Gary Cooper plays Will Kane, the town sheriff. He marries Grace Kelly, a Quaker pacifist who makes him promise to hang up his guns for good and become a businessman. On their wedding day, four outlaws that he previously sent up the river return to terrorize the town. All of the good citizens of the town who should stand up and fight with Coop, urge him instead to run away.
Fearful, alone, and with virtually no hope of success, Cooper decides to stand up to the outlaws. He guns two of them down. The Quaker bride shoots one in the back and then claws the eyes of the last surviving bad guy who is about to kill Cooper.
When the shooting is over, the townsfolk come out to congratulate Cooper.
Disgusted, Cooper takes off his sheriff's star and lets it fall onto the dusty street. He leaves town with Grace Kelly and without saying a word to the cowardly townsfolk who left him to fight terror alone.
I lent "Jr." my DVD of High Noon. Today, we discussed the movie and what Jr. had to say nearly knocked me off my chair.
He says, Gary Cooper was the villain. Cooper shouldn't have used violence, but should have acted like Gandhi. He says there never would have been a shoot-out except for Gary Cooper's character, which he likened to George W. Bush. He wasn't kidding.
Shortly after the Islamic terrorist attack on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon on Sept. 11, 2001, I wrote a column in which I contrasted, High Noon, with the Canadian myth of a Tim Hortons Doughnuts World. I said that we believe in a Canada where our experience of violence is being put into the boards by an opponent in a game of recreational hockey, (but go to the pub and have a brewskie with the same guy after the game). A Canada where we think that everyone has a nice salaried job, a nice spouse, a nice house, a nice son and a nice daughter, and lives in a nice town that is not too small or too big, or too old or too new.
It is our seductive mapled belief that the world wants what Canadians want, and if they just had it there would be no need for guns or bombs or terrorists.
American scholar, Joseph Campbell, awakened generations of readers to the universal power of myth as a means of understanding the experience of our lives in the world. But Campbell also cautioned us to read the myths of other cultures. We were, he observed, too close to the myths of our own culture, and would almost always interpret them as facts.
Jr. has interpreted our maple icing myths as facts. Maybe he's a typical gen Xer, and maybe he's not. However, younger men and women of another Canadian generation are fighting, and unfortunately, some are dying, in Afghanistan. I might be wrong, but I don't think they'd decide that Gary Cooper was the villain in, High Noon.
Bob Friedland is a lawyer and writer, formerly of Calgary, who now lives and works in Richmond, B.C.