Pt 2
Detroit Free Press
It fell in love with tweed jackets and English setters. Even American actors had to be well spoken. And gradually they came to be people with aspirations to class.
Thus the class system among movie stars could say that there were self- evident Americans - like Clark Gable (from Cadiz, Ohio) and Joan Crawford (from San Antonio, Texas). Joan had been Lucille once, from nearly Mexico, my dear, and no better than she should have been. Indeed, Hollywood liked to promote Joan Crawford as the working girl striving for decency and respect. Whereas, Bette Davis and Katharine Hepburn had it by birth. They were from New England, good schools and the stage. They had family background; they had ladylike accents and manners. Hepburn even arrived in Hollywood wearing trousers - and she didn't give a damn in the way that only people born to a certain level of income and social authority can manage. Fred Astaire was an Austerlitz. His sister Adele married an English aristocrat. Gloria Swanson would marry a French count.
Of course, there was comedy in all this climbing. And it took people like Ernst Lubitsch and Preston Sturges to know that penniless French counts were desperate to marry wealthy movie stars. Equally, Archie Leach never forgot that he was a poor Bristol kid acting as if he were Cary Grant, the very model of a perfect trans-Atlantic gentleman.
Best of all, that comedy got into the movies themselves.
Class means hypocrisy, disguise, masquerade and exposure; it brings into play every possible gap between innate honour or nobility and their appearance; it relishes the satirical opportunities in noticing that at San Simeon, say, William Randolph Hearst had a dining hall bought, shipped and recreated from some Italian palace of the 15th century - but with ketchup bottles on the table. From Mark Twain to Billy Wilder, America on the greedy rise has been a rich subject for comedy. And so, in the 1930s, especially, one finds entire genres - screwball comedy, above all - that are fed by that real-life incongruity. In such films as My Man Godfrey, The Awful Truth, Midnight, The Philadelphia Story itself, Nothing Sacred, Twentieth Century, The Lady Eve, Palm Beach Story and many others we see the young and the rich struggling to hold on to their souls and their sanity.
It seems to me that these are among the greatest American films, a term that reminds me to add this: Citizen Kane (1941) is very much about what money does to character, ambition and hope. Kane and his pal, Jed Leland, are prep-school and college boys, able to make wisecracks about class, yet victims of the great myth, too. Kane is supposedly a tragedy, yet it's full of funny lines and an ironic attitude. How easily Preston Sturges might have made a knockout comedy about a poor little rich kid who's lost his sled and calls every woman he meets "Rosebud".
The mutual fascination between Hollywood and Manhattan's cafe society peaked in 1935 when David O Selznick, the son of a Lithuanian immigrant, went into partnership with Jock Whitney, one of the richest men in America, the ultimate in East Coast class and establishment. It was Jewish chutzpah and Wasp money, but the union worked. The two men adored each other, and they made Gone with the Wind along the way. Selznick, of course, was married to one of Mr Mayer's daughters, Irene, and thus she became a model of a Jewish princess who ended her life living in a great suite at the very snob Pierre Hotel on Fifth Avenue, with a Cezanne and a Matisse as company.
That moment and mood have gone now, I fear. America is an increasingly classified society, helplessly measured by money and power. The urge to make fun of the climb has vanished, along with screwball comedy and the kind of song that Cole Porter wrote. Porter himself was American upper class, born rich and sent to Yale, but also showbiz through and through, and in "You're the Top" a 1934 song, he was able to praise merit, excellence and class while still kidding its cult. If you don't know all the words to the song - the answers that go with the exhilarated call "You're the Top" - some of them involve the Whitney stable, Mrs Astor, Pepsodent, the National Gall'ry, Garbo's sal'ry and even cellophane (the mundane and glamour beautifully mixed) and "You're a Bendel bonnet, A Shakespeare sonnet, You're Mickey Mouse". There, for a halcyon moment, was the high society of pure fun.
`High Society' is re-released on 31 May
Hoover. A lot of people said that Mr Mayer and Mr Goldwyn (the classy version of Gelbfisz) had no "class"; that they were notoriously rough, vulgar fellows. But that was all right, for they were merchants to and harbingers of the ultimate classless society, the United States of Ambition. Nor should we scorn their idealism. Mayer and Chaplin believed deeply in carrying pleasure to the humble masses. Still, that urge could carry them in different directions: Chaplin would be accused later of communist leanings, whereas Mr Mayer built himself into a pillar of right- wing respectability and ... class?
You can argue that Louis B never attained "class". On the other hand, no one had more power or money in what was the most glamorous business in America, the one most revered by the masses. And as Marx ought to have said (I mean Groucho), power and money are close enough to class to smell the sweat in the cologne. As the business grew, so it built ornate palaces for movie-going - and called them "the- aters". In Los Angeles in the 1920s and 1930s there was a mania for nightclubs, riding stables, golf courses and country clubs (the most surreal frowned on Jewish membership); to have houses with walled estates; to hire elocution teachers, designers and decorators, psychiatrists and etiquette counsellors - anyone who could smarten up the joint. Hollywood became class-conscious. They started playing polo and croquet.
Nothing stimulated this pressure, or gave it such exposure, as the coming of sound. In the space of a few years, sound meant that slapstick, physical comedy, gave way to verbal humour, and in turn that led to social commentary. A new generation of actors, writers and voice coaches was employed. Coarse, ill-educated, foreign voices gave way to smooth "English" delivery. And, of course, the English were good at that. In the 1930s, a small army of English (or English- seeming) talent arrived (Cary Grant, David Niven, Herbert Marshall, Ray Milland, Errol Flynn, Leslie Howard, Laurence Olivier, Claude Rains, Charles Laughton and so on). Hollywood acquired a cricket club.
It fell in love with tweed jackets and English setters. Even American actors had to be well spoken. And gradually they came to be people with aspirations to class.
Thus the class system among movie stars could say that there were self- evident Americans - like Clark Gable (from Cadiz, Ohio) and Joan Crawford (from San Antonio, Texas). Joan had been Lucille once, from nearly Mexico, my dear, and no better than she should have been. Indeed, Hollywood liked to promote Joan Crawford as the working girl striving for decency and respect. Whereas, Bette Davis and Katharine Hepburn had it by birth. They were from New England, good schools and the stage. They had family background; they had ladylike accents and manners. Hepburn even arrived in Hollywood wearing trousers - and she didn't give a damn in the way that only people born to a certain level of income and social authority can manage. Fred Astaire was an Austerlitz. His sister Adele married an English aristocrat. Gloria Swanson would marry a French count.
Of course, there was comedy in all this climbing. And it took people like Ernst Lubitsch and Preston Sturges to know that penniless French counts were desperate to marry wealthy movie stars. Equally, Archie Leach never forgot that he was a poor Bristol kid acting as if he were Cary Grant, the very model of a perfect trans-Atlantic gentleman.
Best of all, that comedy got into the movies themselves.
Class means hypocrisy, disguise, masquerade and exposure; it brings into play every possible gap between innate honour or nobility and their appearance; it relishes the satirical opportunities in noticing that at San Simeon, say, William Randolph Hearst had a dining hall bought, shipped and recreated from some Italian palace of the 15th century - but with ketchup bottles on the table. From Mark Twain to Billy Wilder, America on the greedy rise has been a rich subject for comedy. And so, in the 1930s, especially, one finds entire genres - screwball comedy, above all - that are fed by that real-life incongruity. In such films as My Man Godfrey, The Awful Truth, Midnight, The Philadelphia Story itself, Nothing Sacred, Twentieth Century, The Lady Eve, Palm Beach Story and many others we see the young and the rich struggling to hold on to their souls and their sanity.
It seems to me that these are among the greatest American films, a term that reminds me to add this: Citizen Kane (1941) is very much about what money does to character, ambition and hope. Kane and his pal, Jed Leland, are prep-school and college boys, able to make wisecracks about class, yet victims of the great myth, too. Kane is supposedly a tragedy, yet it's full of funny lines and an ironic attitude. How easily Preston Sturges might have made a knockout comedy about a poor little rich kid who's lost his sled and calls every woman he meets "Rosebud".
The mutual fascination between Hollywood and Manhattan's cafe society peaked in 1935 when David O Selznick, the son of a Lithuanian immigrant, went into partnership with Jock Whitney, one of the richest men in America, the ultimate in East Coast class and establishment. It was Jewish chutzpah and Wasp money, but the union worked. The two men adored each other, and they made Gone with the Wind along the way. Selznick, of course, was married to one of Mr Mayer's daughters, Irene, and thus she became a model of a Jewish princess who ended her life living in a great suite at the very snob Pierre Hotel on Fifth Avenue, with a Cezanne and a Matisse as company.
That moment and mood have gone now, I fear. America is an increasingly classified society, helplessly measured by money and power. The urge to make fun of the climb has vanished, along with screwball comedy and the kind of song that Cole Porter wrote. Porter himself was American upper class, born rich and sent to Yale, but also showbiz through and through, and in "You're the Top" a 1934 song, he was able to praise merit, excellence and class while still kidding its cult. If you don't know all the words to the song - the answers that go with the exhilarated call "You're the Top" - some of them involve the Whitney stable, Mrs Astor, Pepsodent, the National Gall'ry, Garbo's sal'ry and even cellophane (the mundane and glamour beautifully mixed) and "You're a Bendel bonnet, A Shakespeare sonnet, You're Mickey Mouse". There, for a halcyon moment, was the high society of pure fun.