My view on the proportion thing is the guys were being playful ... I think it's clear they're not incompetent (even if we'd never seen their work before) since the proportions of some looks are perfect. I think alot of the pieces from the "awkward" looks are perfectly wearable if you split them up (which I would anyway, don't like to wear more than one piece of a label at a time), take the belt off or don't cinch it so tight, etc.
My other thought is, especially in this pretty terrible fashion week, anything that's beautiful should be praised, even if it's imperfect, and I feel there are quite a few moments of real beauty and inspiration in this collection.