I hated STID. Such a stain on the Trek legacy, and a blatant ripoff of both WOK and SFS. Also, I didn't find it very clever of the writers to structurally rip off Reboot (sometimes scene for scene) in terms of how plot and characterization was set-up. No wonder the movie overall grossed less than Reboot! Nobody wants to see something so vastly unoriginal, uninspired, and that ignores everything that makes Trek special in the first place.
I still love Reboot. It's what finally enabled to to go back and watch the series. (My real dad was a TNG watcher, so I've always been familiar with Trek, but I had issues with my real dad, so I never had a 'entry in' to watch the franchise until JJ came along.) However, this turd is going to the same place in my mind where I keep Spider-Man 3: it doesn't exist.