I'm wondering about that as well... I remember seeing some unretouched images from Madonna (Vanity Fair 2008) and they relied pretty heavily on post production. These ones are quite ok, tbh but I remember seeing a few from that Tamara de Lempicka LV campaign (FW 2009 I guess?) which looked bad.May I ask where did you find it? It's strange because a lot of the post work could have been avoided with better lighting.